Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Great size. Just big enough for a heavy sock. Looks great. Will have to wIt for winter to see how warm they keep my feet!

These snow boots fit like a pair of comfortable tennis shoes. They are very cute and cozy warm. No break in time, and easy to pull on. No more cold feet in the snow. ?

I ordered these after reading all the stellar reviews. I'm a bit disappointed in that, when I placed a size 10 in my cart, a pop-up suggested a size 9.5. Thinking pop-ups know more than I, I caved and ordered the 9.5. Of course it was too small; I should have stuck with my original idea. As usual Zappos Chat / Live Help was great, and an even exchange was made. When my boots arrived, I was disappointed in that there seems to be little to NO arch support, despite what many reviews say. I'll need to purchase a drug-store support and hope there's enough room to accommodate it. The boots seem warm enough and quite stylish. I'm hoping the arch support will remedy the fact that my feet seem to be floating around in space inside the boots.

Just enough room in the boot to wear a heavy sock! So they are perfect.

These boots are so comfortable out of the box. As the temperatures drop, I’ll be so excited to see how warm they keep my footsies! I always take a half size up in boots and these fit perfectly.

I got the wide in a 10.5. The lace attachments over the bunion areas were hard and uncomfortable for me. Even in the thinnest socks, the boots were too narrow in the toes at the bunion area and in the way the toe tapered. The ankles and calves were too wide because I don't need a wide in those parts. The height of the toe box was a little short for winter socks. Otherwise I liked how lightweight they were because I have tendinitis. I was looking for a snow boot that would double as a boot to drive in and take walks in. I would not use these for sports and hiking though, as the suede overlays on quilted fabric might not withstand much wear and tear from snow shoes or puddles. I wish there were lightweight snow boots that fit women with narrow heel and wide toes and had soft areas for our poor bunions.

These are the only winter boots I wear, this is now my second pair. I bought my first pair ~4 years ago and they are still going strong, but I wanted more than one color. I have thicker than average calves and most winter boots don’t work for me for that reason. These are perfect because the opening actually can go quite wide allowing me to fit my leg in (and then you can lace them up tightly!) They are warm, comfortable to walk in, and waterproof. And, they’re actually affordable!! Couldn’t ask for anything more. My last pair held up great to 4 Michigan winters with everyday use. I am usually a 9 or 9.5 in most shoes and I have a wider foot. I ordered the 9.5 wide width and they fit great. Don’t sleep on these!!

I didn’t get my refund after cancellation this order ?

I wear a 9 - 9 1/2, and bought a 9 1/2. Feels great. Not too boxy in the toe, and there's room for thick socks (but not too much room, which you tweeners know can be a problem). My arches are slightly higher than normal, and i'll need inserts to bring this arch up a little, but the sole feels really nice, otherwise. Color is true, styling is great. Ready for winter and psyched to have these.

Great quality great fit im usually 7 1/2 but i wanted a little more room to fit those thick winter socks havent worn them outside yet

It fits well and looks nice.

I wear a 10, and they said go half up so that you can wear thermo socks with it. I got a 10.5 and it fits great! Haven't gotten thermo socks yet, but it was a good fit without them, so Idk if it would still be comfortable with thick socks. Still, super warm and comfy!

Fit is good. We don't have snow - yet. I will test them in the snow for warmth and for being waterproof. Interior is soft and comfy.

These are awesome boots but they're just to narrow. The toe box was tight and the floor of the boot felt rigid. Not comfortable and not supportive. Its too bad too, I really like them. But this boot is not for fashion, its to get outdoors. If you have any discomfort when you put on a boot or shoe thats for hiking or working, I've learned its a no go. The smallest pinch becomes a big deal after a couple of miles. I thought about getting a bigger size but decided longer isn't going to take away the narrowness of the toe box. BUMMER!

Out-of-the-box comfortable! I wore them all winter and my feet were super happy. They look good on, too. Can't go wrong with these babies.

Boots for my girlfriend for Xmas and she loved them.