Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Got these for my college age daughter. She loves them and still wears them a few years later

Fit was way too small is all…

Just too short in the left toe box for comfort.

I bought these for a two-week trip to the Arctic Circle and Iceland in January. They kept my feet warm, dry, and comfortable through frigid temperatures, deep snow, and icy slush. I even went out one night in the snow without socks and my toes stayed warm, though I wasn't out for long. I generally wear a 7.5 and bought the wide 8 in these, which was the perfect size with thick wool socks. My only issue was that the arch support is pretty nonexistent, so my feet were a bit sore at the end of days where I walked 4-5 miles or more; that said, I think I would probably have room to add in a 3/4 insole for next time I use them for heavy walking. They're super cute and comfortable and a steal for the price.

I bought these for a winter trip. They are nice looking and fairly comfortable, but they definitely have some flaws: 1. Laces are long and come untied easily. They can be a terrible trip hazard. 2. They provide no traction on icy sidewalks. Slip and fall hazard for sure!!!

Comfy and warm!

These boot were fine except the toe box was a little too tight for my bunions. The boots I kept had a wider toe box and were more flexible feeling. These were very warm…. Even warmer than the ones I kept. They would be good for people who have normal feet!

Feels great and wonderful range of motion through the ankle. Will be great for snowy dog walks this winter.

These boots are so cute and fun to wear! They are very handsome, comfy and cozy. Most definitely would wear all winter long since they dress up your winter clothes! Highly recommended! ;)

Comfortable right out the box

Ugly boots. Cheap feeling and looking. Columbia has gone downhill.

These are very inexpensive looking snow boots. I guess you get what you pay for. It seems the brand has gone downhill. Black suede looks more green in person.

They are really comfortable!

Wow. All I need to say about these is that I love them. Took them to Finland for a month's visit in the winter and wore them many times.

I put my own insoles in when I tried, so I can't comment on the arch support. I was disappointed to find that the sole is very flexible, which is less support than I like. In the pictures, I thought the 'fur' was cute, but when I tried on I realized that I would always have to tuck my pants in because the 'fur' sticks out so you can't pull your pants over w/out seeing the bump, which is a limitation. The left wasn't wide enough, but the right was reasonably comfortable.

Not terrible but looked cheap and not the greatest.

These are a nice-looking boot. They are probably more than I need in our moderate coastal California climate near San Francisco. They are really wide and require a super-thick sock, and when you walk in them they kind of bend in a weird way. I'd give them a 3.5/5 stars, but not a 4. I think they'd be great (4 or 5 stars) in snowy conditions like Lake Tahoe in winter.