Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

These were just too clunky for me so I returned.

I was not a fan of these... stiff, no support, and a little too “western” looking. The zipper in back would not zip up.

Good looking boots but ordered 11 M and they were extremely narrow and small in the calf.

This boot fit as a B width not as a W.

I wanted to like this boot, but it felt stiff, too large around the heel, slid up and down on my foot when I walked, and the leather looked rubbery. The olive color looked really nice and would be useful, but unfortunately, these boots were just too uncomfortable and are going back.

Really pretty boot but fits weird - size seemed overall correct (10.5 M) but they were too loose/bunchy at ankle and too tight at top of calves.

Length was good, but width was way too wide. Boot was extremely sloppy on my foot and my heel slipped up and down. I felt like i had a pair of big water boots on.... i really, really wanted to like these, but i simply cannot wear them as my feet just sloshed around. Also way too big in the calf region.

I ordered the whiskey, and ended up returning them. If you have wider feet, or would like to wear thick socks with these boots, I'd go half a size up. I wasn't a big fan of the leather, which felt and looked cheap. It just didn't feel like real leather, rather it felt more like PU used for handbags. Because of this, the price seemed way overblown, so I sent them back. I ended up getting a pair of fryes, and you can really feel the difference in leather quality.

These fit great and initially I was excited. Then I wore them and noticed scuffing after my first day wearing these! The scuff have increased each time I’ve worn these boots. So my suggestion? Great boots until you have to wear them more than 5 minutes. Very disappointed.

Boots were beautiful, foot was true to size, width was great. I could not zip up. I have 15" calves and the reviews I read said these were 15". Others said they had big calves and they fit so I hoped. Nope.. not even close. I hated returning them too..

I like the style and quality. I'm older, 5' and around 140lb. I usually need (and ordered) a 6W to accommodate wider toes. The calf was close fitting as one would hope and expect with a riding boot. But I had to return these because the heel was unusually wide and relatively loose, which unfortunately would make it slip while walking. Worse, although this is technically a wide sized, round toe boot, the toe shape was quite sharply tapered like a narrow-toed western boot, cramping the ball and toes as if it were a medium 5 1/2. Wide heel and narrow toes doesn't work for a wide size - most of us, especially those older, need a closer fitting heel and wider around the toes. Also, arch support would have been nice but not included in the fit, and there isn't enough room inside to add an insert. Because of the loose fitting heel, ordering a half size up would make it slip more.

It was a little small, but I have trouble with straight 11s. However, the leather looked and felt low quality, and the fit around the ankles was so baggy it was really uncomfortable. I also didn't like where the back of the boot hit with the actual heel. Not my style. Maybe they work for a lighter boot, but I want something for colder weather/fashion.

When I first tried them on at home, they felt comfortable and looked stylish and cute. Very true to size as I am usually a 9.5-10 (more like a 10 in boots) and the 9.5 fit me perfectly. However, I wore them to work today. I am wearing cropped jeans and short socks so there is a portion of my ankle skin touching the boot. It is extremely uncomfortable and feels like something keeps digging into my skin. I tried to pull up my socks to help protect the skin but it still hurts. It looks loose in the ankle/baggy, too as I wear them today, which isn't as stylish. I wish I had figured this out before I wore them outside because I would have returned them. Maybe thicker socks would help but these regular socks don't.

The first item I bought in the wrong size for me then I bought a second pair and one feet came larger than the other. It’s a nice looking boot but not really comfortable and the quality does not seem reliable

The foot part of the boot felt great but I couldn't get them zipped more than about halfway up my calf. I've never needed to order wide leg boots and in fact have a narrow foot. These run very narrow in the leg. Very cute in the box with great details and soft leather - I am bummed to return them.

I ordered my size, 8w. I could not get my foot in the boot. The instep is so small that it was impossible. Have to return.

This shoe looks nice on line but the fit is terrible. I have pretty standard size feet. The space between the bottom of the foot and top of the foot before it hits the ankle is so small I couldn't get my foot into it. Shaft circumference also seems large even though I didn't order the wide calf.

Look great, but I could feel the pattern of the tread through the sole! Never had that experience before....

Love these boots, but they are definitely only a "Wide" by perhaps a millimeter.

It took me a while to determine my size in these boots. I typically wear a 9, but wound up with an entirely different size. It seems that all the trying on, and back and forth was not worth it though. Just a few weeks later, and the boots are falling apart. I'm so disappointed, and wish that I could return them for a refund. I've worn them to the office, and out to dinner a handful of times. You wouldn't know it though. With the way they're wearing, you would think they're years old. It's to the point that the leather has cracked in spots, the soles are in horrific shape. I've spent far less on boots than I did on this pair, and had them last much, much longer. I would not recommend purchasing these boots... At all.

Uncomfortable; poor fit.

I saw these on Nordstrom's website and had to have them. Sooo...I looked them up on my Zappos app and ordered them. I was really disappointed upon receipt because the boot really wasn't the quality I was expecting. They just looked and felt cheap. Maybe a different color would've looked better.