Name: Penny Leather Riding Boots
Brand: Sam Edelman
SKU: 8039695
Price: 199.99 USD
Availability: InStock
Rating: 4 (1185 reviews)

Reviews

4.0

(1,185)

Write A Review

Customers Say

Customers praise these boots for their classic style, perfect navy shade, and soft buttery leather that's beautifully made. They find them exceptionally comfortable, with feet not getting sore, and one customer notes the low heel makes them suitable for all-day wear. The fit receives mixed feedback, with several customers finding them too narrow, while the zipper functionality is also mixed, with some praising the back zipper while others report issues with it sticking.

AI-generated from the text of customer reviews.

Select To Learn More

75%True to size

68% Felt true to width

82% Moderate arch support

Sort by:

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

I've been on the search for a riding boot for a while now. These boots are awesome! Very soft, well made and even has arch support inside. I am petite (5ft, 115lbs and a runner with muscular calves. These fit great! They hit right below my knee and feel broken in. I love the zipper in back and minimal hardware. It's enough to give the boot personality without being tacky. I recently bought Tory Burch boots but in no way shape or form are they made for short people or anyone with a calf. I had to return them and very disappointed. I also tried the Frye Melissa button backs and they were the runner up but a tad too tall and fit more snug all around. These SE's have room to wear with skinnys and I love the diagonal shaft. The inside feels like soft suede.

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, October 15, 2013

95 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

These boots have the potential to be perfect, but they missed the mark. The first issue is the deal breaker for me - the whiskey color looks absolutely NOTHING like the photo! The photo shows a beautiful, rich, almost distressed leather in a deep whiskey shade. In person, the boots are a flimsy, cheap-looking light brown. No "whiskey" color at all - just light brown. At first I thought I'd received a dud pair - but I exchanged for another pair and they're exactly the same. Cheap leather that resembles pleather. My second issue was the width - I ordered a size "wide" (regular calf, wide foot) and it's narrower than some of my regular shoes. So I'd say the shoe runs extremely narrow. Zappos really needs to change the photo for this product in "whiskey" because it's false advertising at this point. Zappos has great customer service so I know I can return the boots, but it's a waste of time and resources and money to go back and forth with shipments because the item pictured is not the item received. Disappointed - the search for boots continues.

Chimera, Zappos Customer, October 4, 2016

64 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

I just received these from Zappos and was so thrilled with the style, I immediately put them on! They are classic. The leather is soft and the inside lining is quality. Most importantly, the sole is substantial. Not in a bad way, I am just coming from an old pair of boots that would make my socks wet the second I stepped in any snow. I also had a few odd things I was looking for in new boots: they stand up and stay up on my calves and you don't have to constantly pull them up. Secondly, I also wanted to be able to cross my legs without having any embellishments make it uncomfortable. The minimal zipper and clasp are out of the way!

Lindsay, Zappos Customer, February 13, 2014

61 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

These don't look anything like the picture. They are orange, with an ombré black toe. They smell good, like genuine leather, but not as cute as they look in the picture. Also, I ordered wide width, and I couldn't even get my foot in the boot. Big disappointment.

Jessica, Zappos Customer, August 29, 2017

41 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

These boots are very good quality. The leather is soft and the design details are great. I usually wear an 8 or 8 1/2, I got the 8 1/2 and they were too big, so if you are on the fence about two different sizes, I would suggest going smaller. I loved the boots but only gave a four out of five stars rating because they were too wide at the top for my leg and I prefer the height of boots be closer to the knee. Excellent quality boot overall!

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, September 30, 2012

35 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 1,180 Customer Reviews

Customer Photos and Videos

Sort by:

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, October 15, 2013

95 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

Chimera, Zappos Customer, October 4, 2016

64 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Lindsay, Zappos Customer, February 13, 2014

61 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Verified Purchase

Review for Zappos VIP Points (What's this?)

Jessica, Zappos Customer, August 29, 2017

41 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Overall

Comfort

Style

Anonymous, Zappos Customer, September 30, 2012

35 Found this review helpful.

Runs SmallRuns Large

Runs NarrowRuns Wide

Poor SupportGreat Support

Read Additional 1,180 Customer Reviews

Sam Edelman
Penny Leather Riding Boots
Women's

Customer Questions

How It Was Worn

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

About Zappos

Customer Service

Resources

Explore Zappos

How It Was Worn

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Customer Questions

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Sam EdelmanPenny Leather Riding BootsWomen's

Product Information

Size Chart

Customer Questions

How It Was Worn

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Free Shipping and Free Returns

How It Was Worn

Free Shipping and Free Returns

Customer Questions

Reviews

Customers Say

Customer Photos and Videos

Sam Edelman
Penny Leather Riding Boots
Women's