Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

Leather was soft. Nice simple style. Problem is although 7.5W, doesn't feel like a wide boot so I must return.

I loved the comfort of the footbed, but the calf was uncomfortably tight even on my bare leg.

I bought these for my 19 year old and she does love them. She is 5'7" and has long legs and they fit well.Unfortunately, the zipper broke after a couple of wears so I'll be returning them.

I usually wear a 8.5, sometimes 9, and I was a 9 in these. Took a while to break in. Don't feel uncomfortable when I put them on, but my feet always hurt at the end of the day in these. It's really difficult to find boots that are enormous on skinny legs, so I put up with the discomfort for not looking like I'm wearing wellies. Don't regret buying these in black, but I won't buy them in another color (whereas I probably would have bought more if they were more comfortable).

This boot would be great if it was truly a wide width, unfortunately the calf is very tight. I usually wear a 9.5 or 10 but go with 10 with boots for sock room and bc I have found boots tend to run small. If the calf fit comfortably (just barely zipped with a thin pair of jeans), I believe a 9.5 would have been fine even with boot socks. It seems like they allowed for slightly more width in the boot (as their brand runs narrow) and there is more room in the ankle but if you have muscular calves or bigger calves, skip these.

The material looked/felt very cheap. The leather is too thin to keep its shape so the ankles of the boot looked all wrinkled and ugly. I was disappointed because the fit and style were nice, but the overall effect looked terrible, so I returned them.

These are lovely boots made from very soft buttery leather. The picture is accurate for color. The only thing that I disliked is they slouch. If you don't mind wrinkling at the ankle, these are a great boot for the price. Also, I have bunions and the wide fit okay.

If I had seen these in a brick and mortar store, I wouldn’t have tried them on. The leather looks cheap (like recycled paper), and there just isn’t any wow factor. I tried them on with a hose thin sock and they were incredibly tight, no support either. I’m a 5’4”, 132 lb athlete and these barely fit around my calves with skinny jeans. The whole feel was just cheap, like something you’d pick up for under $100.

These boots are too narrow, so they are going back. Nice leather, though.

Overall I like these boots, and I think through more wear they will break in, but these are SO NARROW. I have a medium width foot and have never needed wide shoes before, but when I first put these on, I thought I was going to have to exchange for a wide. (I did not exchange them though.) The size (length) was perfect - I always wear an 8.5 in boots and these were spot on - but I felt like my foot was suffocating. I was also upset with the lack of arch support - I've come to expect this for $50-75 boots, but not $150 boots! The shaft of the boot was also super flimsy... this is not necessarily a complaint since they seem to breathe better than many other boots with thicker materials, but I was expecting something sturdier from the photos. I like the style overall but I will note that the texture shown in the photos for the black boots is not quite right - no complaints but the material is smoother than in the photos.

Wide? Nope! It's always tricky to find a nice boot that comes in wide. I thought I finally found a great style in a boot that would fit. Sadly that wasn't the case.

Although listed as a wide, I think this meant it was probably C-width. Way too tight for my D-width feet. It was also a little difficult to zip/unzip at the very bottom. It also didn't close over my not super big calves. I am short (5ft) so this might be only for people with much longer legs. Super cute though.

Great looking boot- but bt the leg is way too wide for my average calf. This is the size of a wide leg shaft. This booot is for a wider leg fyi.

I was hesitant to purchase these boots but after reading the reviews I thought I would try them. I have more athletic calves so I purchased the extended calf, did much care for how they stuck out on the sides, making me look like puss in boots also the foot area was very narrow, I still liked it well enough to go back and order the regular with in a wide, however those also turned out to be a dud, the wider foot area was fine but I couldn’t get the zipper past mid calf. Also the material looks a little cheap. Both pairs are going back.

Was ready to keep these gorgeous boots that fit perfectly until I discovered how flimsy the soul is. It actually bows out from the weight of your foot. This would be really bad for anyone's foot. Therefore I cannot recommend this shoe.

I ordered the 8 in normal width, and they were too narrow (returned). Then, I ordered the 8 in wide width, and they were too big (returned). Just can't get it right!

The boots are adorable. The width is far too narrow to the point they pinched. I wear a size 5.5 and have very narrow feet. The boot shaft was pretty snug, but fit me perfectly. The leather is beautifully crafted. I am returning because they are just too narrow and the zipper at the back of the boot was really hard to zip. I was worried I was going to break the zipper with the level of effort it took.

unfortunately had to return these very pretty boots. I ordered my size....an 8 1/2 wide and the width was not wide enough. There was a large gap in the heel area that made the length feel too long.

I've been looking for a nice leather riding boot in a wide width and thought these would be it. They are very nice looking, and the calf shaft fit perfect, however they are not wide width. So, I can't understand why they are listed as wide width. So, although they are very nice looking, they sadly are going to be returned.

I have thin calves, size 11 foot with high arches and found Eric Micheal to be both a better leather, fit and arch support.

Stiff and tight. I ordered black and grey and had to send back.

These boots have the unusual combination of being too narrow in the forefoot and too wide in the heel for my feet. While my forefeet were noticeably sticking out over the side of the sole, my heels were sliding up and down as I walked. Since I have feet towards the narrow end of the spectrum, these boots will be too narrow for many size 12 feet.

Gorgeous boot, but with my high arch, I just couldn’t fit comfortably in the boot!

I call these the Goldy Locks Boots, I read the reviews first before purchasing and some people said they were too wide, some said they were too tight (me), and some people said they were just right. Love the look of them, and foot fit the boot but I couldn't zip them up. I wish with boots that there was a calf size measurement. I am returning these and trying another pair that were marked as wide.

I am so sad that these boots didn't work out for me, especially because there are so many things I love about them. The leather is great, it's soft and looks lush, feels great and the color was just what I was looking for, and I love the way they look on my legs!! The problem for me was the insole has a raised area that hits my metatarsal area in the wrong spot and is quite uncomfortable for me. I hope I can find a boot that looks and feels as good as these!