Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

Very comfy right out of box. Been looking for a long time for gray boots, love the color!

These boots are very comfortable.they look great on. I usually wear between a 6-6.5. I ordered a 6.5 and they are slightly longer than I expected. They are fine with thicker socks.

I ordered this boot in the Whiskey color and love the rich color. I have narrow feet but slightly wider calves so have a hard time finding something that will fit me since wide calf boots are way too wide. The 7.5 (my normal size) fit in the foot area but were a little snug zipping up so I exchanged for an 8 and they fit much better. I ordered the M width and if you don't have narrow feet I'd recommend ordering the W width or going up at least a half size. I liked the narrowness of the foot was a plus for me, but could see it being a problem for others. Overall very lovely boot!

i have never been able to find a good tall boot in this color brown in a nice material at the store - but I finally have my perfect boot. The leather is soft, and the color is perfect. I'm 5'4" and 155 lbs, and fits nicely around my calf. The material is stiff enough to hold its shape even when not being worn. Am now hoping it lasts as long as other reviewers have said. Highly recommended.

These boots are stylish and felt comfortable as soon as I put them on. I liked the price and the color of the leather is great.

Wow! I love these boots. The leather is buttery soft. So comfortable immediately. Love the back zipper, with the snap closure. No over dressing on these boots, with buckles, bows, etc. Simple beauty. Comfortable style. They fit my difficult feet. Little snug at top, but believe they will stretch. Sam Edelman Penny is a great item, great price. Thanks Sam Edelman Penny

Great boots! The Leather is buttery soft and has a distressed look to them with some slight imperfections and scuffs. I am true size 10 and they fit perfectly. I have narrow feet and the footbed is definitely pretty narrow so it was even a little snug on me. I got the grey frost color and it's a true cool light grey. They are very comfortable and they seem well made!

These boots are exactly what I was looking for, a casual pair, but a little nicer. I have the Whiskey color and they go with everything from pants to dresses. Very comfortable, they fit perfectly over my pants with no problem and I usually have an issue with that since most boots around my calves are tight. Soft leather so no bruising or rubbing on my ankles. Only suggestion is to order a wide unless you have narrow feet. I have regular width feet and don't own any wide shoes, but when I ordered these in normal width they were super narrow, even with thin socks. I exchanged for the wide and they fit perfect like a normal width. My friend has these boots and also says the normal width is tight on her. Overall great boots, perfect fit now, and I expect them to last a while with the thick heel and sole.

I love these boots! I have a pair in black that I wear to work in the winter, and am planning to buy a pair in Whiskey brown for weekends after seeing them on a friend. They're very comfortable and look quite sharp. Be sure to waterproof them before wearing and store them upright (I use the foam supports they were packaged with), and they'll last you well.

These Boots are the Business!! Sharp Styling, Comfortable and I wear a size 12, I hope to order the Cognac color ones??

I've been shopping for boots like these for the past two years. I like the look of them with skinny jeans and leggings and with skirts. Unless I was prepared to pay $400 and up for a pair, I had no luck. These boots fit the bill for me. I love them!

Very comfortable stylish boot. My calves are very wide and I have no issues wearing them with my jeans. Worth every penny.

I usually wear a 10W. I was so excited to find a cute riding boot that came in wide width, but the 10W was too small for me. I sized up to an 11 and I think they are going to work out just fine. They are a bit snug, but if past experience is any indicator they will loosen up as I wear them. These boots are amazing. The leather is so soft. I am 6'0" tall and I love the height and circumference of the boot shaft. I was torn between Whiskey and Olive, but ultimately went with Whiskey. It is a classic color that I think will work with everything. Highly recommend these boots.

I have only worn these boots once, but I got a couple of compliments on them when I did. I ordered my regular 8.5 and they fit well. They are very comfortable and I'm extremely pleased with them.

I love these. I have athletic calves tho, so they are snug in the calf but a little wide at the top. keeping them anyway bc they're GORGEOUS.

I was SO excited to receive these and was not disappointed! I got the Whiskey color and I love it. True to size, comfy, and super cute.

After a lengthy search, I finally found my new black boots! I really like these a lot. The leather is soft and not too shiny, and the asymmetrical top gives them some interest. They are a nice balance of dress and casual - very versatile.

Great color, great boot. Love Sam Edelman and this boot did not disappoint. Good quality and perfect to wear with leggings, dresses or tuck in skinny jeans. I love them and will be wearing them a lot this fall and winter.

I bought these boots and loved them. Great soft leather, and great look. Unfortunately had to return as I'm really short and came a little to high on my legs. So sad because truly one of the most comfortable boots I've tried. Buy them you won't be sorry!

I wear 7.5 size shoe. This boot was way too tight. Had a hard time taking the boot off. Had to return.

Loved the color and style of these boots! Unfortunately, the fit was poor for someone like me who needs width in the toe, not in the calf. :-(

I've been looking for a pair of brown/cognac boots for quite some time. These are fabulous, they are buttery soft, comfortable and stylish. Even my husband was impressed. I can't wait to wear them!

These are beautiful, classic riding boots. The Whiskey color is beautiful and the leather is very nice quality for the price. Good sturdy sole with a solid heel and tread. They are slim fitting but are offered in Wide Calf as well. The slim fit worked for me with tights and jeans. They look more expensive than than they are. Very pleased with these boots.