Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Holden Plain Toe Oxford

Great shoe, but squeaky sole on some floor surfaces at work.

Love the shoes look and comfort. Am concerned about how easily they will get spots on the uppers and how best to clean.

I did not keep the dress sneaker/shoe because of the possibility that the leather would crease near the toe. They were very comfortable and the fit was a bit large for me as I am 1/2 size smaller in the sneaker/shoe department whereas my dress shoes are a perfect fit at a certain size 1/2 up.

Very user-friendly can walk miles a day with no issues!

Comfortable shoes, but a little stiff out of the box

I love it

Great comfort, very light weight, but a bit spongy to walk in.

Shoe arrived quickly and has good quality and comfort!

Glad I bought these shoes. They fit as expected, look and feel good; what else is there?

sharp looking shoe both for dressy or hanging out in jeans

bought for grandson,,,unable to determine answers to area marked ' Cons' as of this time since he has not worn them enough to determine look good and feel good so far

Very comfortable. Love the color of the leather. Would prefer a different color in the soles.

Like leather soled shoes.

Great looking shoe- heel backing is not rugged enough to slip on and off- it is breaking down.

Comfortable,elegant and beautiful shoes, color as expected

Very good shoes, light, excellent design

I picked up a pair of the brown tumbled nubuck Holden's at a nearby J&M store just prior to them being closed by COVID. I have been a size 11 in some J&M shoes, and a size 10.5 in others, just depending on the style. The salesperson measured my foot again, and sold me the 11s. After wearing them only 3-4 times, the shoe has become extremely loose in the foot, leading to some discomfort. It's really too bad, I love the look of the shoe and the comfort would be likely awesome, but they are just too darned big.

would recommend same shoe with better cushioning around top edge and heel

Initial thoughts are good but really haven't gotten to wear yet.

The leather feels soft but the shoes feel stiff and will require a breaking in. They seem comfortable but I have only worn them in the house.

Very comfortable sole, narrow shoe recommendation is get a wide

I found shoe to be stylish, comfortable and versatile. Complemented my dress slacks I wear to work or jeans on casual Friday. Nice shoe. I own 2 pairs.

These shoes are so comfortable I have wore them once for 8 hours so it's early but as of now I will say the are the most comfortable shoes I have worn in this style. I got a number of compliments on them so I will be looking to buy more in other colors.

My regular size is 11M but shoes were 1/2 too big