Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Holden Plain Toe Oxford

Great Shoe All J&M products are great.

Great shoe for todays business dress. Very comfortable to walk in all day with a great look.

Quality shoe, great look. Fits well although they run a little large

Super comfortable & the Wide fits me great. Can dress these up or down.

Love the feel of the shoe and the look. Unfortunately, I ordered the wrong size and have sent them back and am hoping I filled out the paperwork correctly. I reordered a size 10 and returned the 9.5

Nice looking shoe. Very comfortable. I was looking for a little more casual style.

Very happy with my purchase, I have been tired of the dsw leatherette shoes Ive been purchasing. I wanted real leather and something that would last. These shoes look amazing and feel awesome. They broke in quickly. Very happy and will be definitely getting my next pair from Johnston and Murphy.

There were no options for wide sizes. Medium is tight but I alike the shoes.

Nice shoes, but ran small.

Comfortable, beautiful shoes! Havent had them long but theyve certainly met my expectations so far

Shoe looks great and is comfortable to wear. I have wide feet and the W worked perfect. side at back end of the foot is a little high and stiff and rubs the ankle

Shoe looks great and is comfortable to wear. I have wide feet and the W worked perfect. side at back end of the foot is a little high and stiff and rubs the ankle

I dont care for the color. Too yellow green shade leather. (I prefer reddish)

I have never been disappointed with a Johnston & Murphy shoe. This is my first time purchasing on-line only because the local outlet has a very limited selection of shoes in wide widths. This shoe is comfortable for every day, all day wear.

Theyre good shoes but not great. The back rubs my heel. The frustrating part is my favorite shoes ever was a similar model shoe from J&M that they apparently stopped making and this was the closest thing i could find and theyre just not as good. Bummer!

They're good shoes but not great. The back rubs my heel. The frustrating part is my favorite shoes ever was a similar model shoe from JM that they apparently stopped making and this was the closest thing i could find and they're just not as good. Bummer!

This is my second pair of these shoes. To me, that says something. I love the way they look with jeans and the first pair lasted a long time. This pair has been a lot harder to break-in or Id have give them five stars.

This is my second pair of these shoes. To me, that says something. I love the way they look with jeans and the first pair lasted a long time. This pair has been a lot harder to break-in or I'd have give them five stars.

I love the casual style of the shoe, it's light, comfortable, and soft. I love the way they look with my sports apparel. NICE! Now the con it could be softer around the ankle. Other than that a nice casual shoe. Looking forward to purchasing more in different colors.

Ordered 8.5, shipped an 8

This is my second pair of Holden plain toe shoes. I love the shoe, they're very comfortable. So I ordered a second pair, same size 10, just in a different color. The second pair arrived recently and it's noticeably smaller. So much so I couldn't fit my foot into the shoe even though it is marked as the same size my original pair are marked. I did notice on the inside tongue of the shoe, the original pair were manufactured in Vietnam. The second pair was manufactured in India. I am highly disappointed in the quality control displayed by this change in manufacturing sites. Size 10 should be standard across all manufacturing lines, especially if you want to sell online.

True fit. It could have a bit more substantial sole.

The most uncomfortable shoe ever. So painful I had to take them off walking back to my office from the restaurant two blocks away. Both on the tops of my toes and backs of my heals which both have blisters after the first wearing. Bought these after having to return Upton Plain Toe shoes becaues they started falling apart after about 8 or 10 wearings. I would expect this from shoes bought somewhere like Marshalls for $20, but $155 shoes should be good quality.

They are great, however the top of the heel takes a bit to break in.