Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Holden Plain Toe Oxford

This shoe was very narrow and had to be sent back. The original width was a medium.

They look very nice. I have not wear them, tried on and fit well.

I picked a pair these shoes up last year to put in the rotation, I probably wear them twice a month and I just noticed today around the ball of my both of my feet. The soul is separating from the top part of the shoe. Huge disappointment because I dont think this can be fixed.

This size is a half size too small. Its also very noisy on hard surfaces

The shoes I bought bring comfort and style. The shoes always look good in the business environment.

Very comfortable. My other J&M shoes run larger.

I purchased 5 other shoes Freon J&M and the size were consistently spot on. However, this particular model is not size 10.5M as stated on the order and marked on the shoes.

Lot more comfortable than it looks, this probably the plainest looking shoe in the J&M line. It is surprisingly comfortable. With the low gray sole it does not look like it but there is comfort. the style is very very plain. I have wide feet and wear orthotics and have found J&M shoes really very on their toe box widths a lot. As this has broken in, I may have not needed the wide's, and I have a regular width on my Upton laces up which are the best. But others that do not have the same toe box. Wish there were more stores that carried the shoes so they could be tried on first.

Im wearing these with a business suit and was worried they may look too casual. They in fact look just like any other dress show but of course they wear like sneakers. They could have used a less plasticy sole but for the price these are a great buy

These are quite uncomfortable and they dig into my heel I wore them one day and I had blisters by the end of the day. Theres NO cushioning on the back.

Really comfortable shoe - softer than a sneaker. Smart looking. I found the shoes a little more narrow than other J&M shoes of the same size.

Really comfortable shoe - softer than a sneaker. Smart looking. I found the shoes a little more narrow than other JM shoes of the same size.

Narrow, very uncomfortable to wear like most of J& M dress shoes.

The shoe is comfortable , but a little stiff at the ankle .

Comfortable width is perfect but a little long

Comfortable width is perfect but a little long

Ive worn them infrequently because they are so small and didnt want to completely waste my money. I waited beyond the return date to send them back.

Ive had 2 pairs of Holden plain toe that fit great, these are cut differently and are too narrow. Sadly,

Great style & Confort

The toe box is a bit smaller than I have experienced on your other shoes of the same size, pressing a bit on both my big toe nails.

Wrong size in box. Upon reorder did not have my size

I received this shoe as a gift. Im wore them to work one day and quickly found out the cut hard at the ankle and back of the heel. I had to place bandaids along the ankle and heel/achilles line just to get through the day. Since theyve been worn, Im stuck with them. I may try again properly padded to see if they break in. If they dont, then Im stuck with a worthless shoe.

Im not gonna lie..shoe is a little tight and I thought Id like them a bit betterhopefully the more they get broken in Ill like thembought 2 pairs

My shoes were well packaged. The shoes were in perfect condition when they arrived at my house. The shoes were an exact fit and Im happy I ordered these shoes.

Somewhat uncomfortable at the ankle but otherwise true to size and stylish