Customer Reviews Hoka Challenger ATR 5

Nice show but I returned. Something about the fit wasn’t right. Arch support in wrong place and ran slightly large. But I have problem feet so maybe my fault

I ordered these to replace an older pair of Challenger ATRs that have some mileage on them. Even new out of the box these shoes did not have the padding and comfort that my old ATRs did. I ended up going with the Stinson ATR which had much better padding especially in the forefoot where I need it most. The arch support on the Stinsons is also quite good. Sad because this was a great shoe. I actually bought two pairs at the time because I was worried they might change it and it appears so. : (

Once inserting my Sole shoe inserts and heel support the shoe was perfect. Plenty of room for all sizes of orthotic insoles and accessories. The sole absorbs a lot of shock and my joints feel better after long walks. Which are 1-3 a day everyday. (I have a dog). The laces provide extra support around the arch area where I need it most. Enough toe box room. The shoe fabric is a bit stiff looking and the gray is a tad institutional but my feet were very happy so I over look that. Otherwise they are decent looking shoes. Run a bit large but I don’t mind because of the insoles. If they made less shoes with bright white soles ...

I love the sole of this shoe. Sadly the upper is fairly stiff and rubbed/pinched the top of my foot with ever step. They are going back. They seem like great shoes just not for me.

My first time wearing Hokas. I work on concrete all day and this shoe has been amazing. No more foot pain. They are great. Can't wait to get a second pair.

I've had 4 surgeries on my right foot and one on my left foot. I need a wide toe box, especially on the right. When I saw that the Hoka One One Challenger ATR 5 came in a medium and wide with, I decided to try the shoe. I wear trail running shoes most of the summer, because I'm often on trails with my dogs and I like the light weight and the grip. The Challenger ATR 5 is perfect. I ordered the medium width and the toe box fits well, even if I'm wearing my toe splint. The shoe is cushioned well and does not rub at all. The Challenger ATR 5, also, has a longer tongue than the Hoka One One Stinson, so when the shoe is tied, the 'knot'/shoestrings don't cut into the area of your ankle that flexes. Arch support is something I don't usually notice, unless it's too much...or none at all. This arch support was noticeable when I first put the shoe on. However, I've worn the shoe for about 6 hours now and don't notice the arch support at all.

I love my new Hoka challenger 5 !

I was hoping that the Challenger would be as comfortable as the Clifton 6, but, alas, they were a bit too narrow - boo hoo!

I liked the shoe when I tried it on, but when I was going to wear it for the first time, I noticed the back of the shoe folded down and there was some rubbing on the heel cuff. I figured out that the foam did not continue up the entire back of the heel so it was creating this rub point and because there was no foam there, when you put the shoe on, that part of the shoe folded inside the shoe. So even though I liked them, my pair was defective and I am sending them back.

Love these sneakers. I wear size 7 and these are a bit loose but so comfortable and supportive for workout classes and walking. They look great and I got a great price!

I love this brand. I am trying to replace my Speedgoat 2. No longer available. These shoes felt and looked very clunky! May have felt comfortable but didn't give them a chance.

Very cushiony shoe with a low toe- to-heel differential. Good for minimalist running or walking.

These fit much different than the older version. They seem to be wider and not as flexible. I find them to be too clunky for me. They have great cushioning but my foot is much too narrow for these.

Forefront of the shoe felt fine. I have a problem sometimes with the side of the heel being too high for my foot and unfortunately, this one of those shoes. I actually thought the shoe was better looking than a lot of Hoka's I've had.

These shoes offer a high level of support and "squish." However, for me, it felt like my foot was swimming in the them (too wide - and I have a wide-ish foot/rarely say a shoe is too wide). My favorite Hokas are the Speedgoats.