Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Button 2

I bought these just looking for something to wear to the office and now I even wear them out

I have these in an 8.5, brown, and they are absolutely gorgeous. I wear an 8.5 M and they fit as my other Frye 8.5 boots and shoes fit. I am between sizes so I also tried the 8, however, it was too tight on my foot so I sized up. The width is perfect for an average calf (13.75 in my case). The straight leg jeans I had on went right into the boot with room to spare. If anything, the opening might be a bit large; I had on the regular ones, not wide calf. I liked the black too, but the colors in the brown were too gorgeous to pass up. The only thing that worries me is they are slippery on carpet, but are ok on tile, hard wood, etc. I usually buy Fryes with the lug heel for traction.

These are the nicest most comfortable boots I have ever purchased. Quality of leather is exceptional.

After four tries, I finally found the right Frye boots! Apparently I have ginormous calves, and I wanted boots that didn't have a stretchy back, and these it the bill. The shale color is a cool brownish gray, and I can already tell they will gets lots of use. Just ordered the black, hope they are just as awesome. Merry Christmas to me!

Bought the Melissa Button boots in black 5 years ago and have worn the heck out of them. So comfortable and still look great. Wanted to go for the brown this time for some variety - do not think I will be disappointed.

My 3rd pair of Fryes and not disappointed! So happy I decided to order the extended calf based on reviews. The fit is perfect. Looking forward to adding these to my rotation. Thanks Frye.

Theses are one of my favorite boots, so soft and fit like a dream. I own other Frye boots which I love. Very happy girl.

I just got these boots in yesterday, and love them! They do run about a half too full size too large i am normally between a 7.5 and 8 in shoes and in my Frye boots (usually leaning more towards a 7.5 but sometimes an 8) I own several pairs of Frye boots as well as there shoes, I have the Jenna, harness 12r, Veronica slouch tall, and Veronica tanker for a couple references, as well as the ivy slip on and the sienna cross strap, and run a 7.5 in all but 2( the tanker and the sienna) these I did go down to a 7 and there will be room in the length once I break them in width wise for some warmer socks, I had purchased both the 7 and 7.5 based on the other review that they ran large, and the 7.5 was big and flopped to the floor as I walked, definitely to much room, so I kept the 7 which was perfect, to be honest I didn't try it but the 6.5 might have even fit as well but I like just a little room in the toe bed. For reference I'm 5'7" normally 117lbs and am usually a size 2/26 in clothes, my foot size is on the narrow side of normal but I'm not a true narrow at all. I am 7 months pregnant right now but my feet never change size or swell during pregnancy and I will say even with the added weight of the baby these boots are very comfy so I know they will be even more so after I'm not preggers anymore, I highly recommend these as a good fall/winter staple boot, they will go with anything and will only get more comfy as I wear them, I did end up getting them in the cogniac color and love the more rugged look of this leather and color.

These boots are beautiful and true to size. The leather is of exquisite quality and I love the button detail. They will be my fall and winter go to's for years to come! And of course, the leather smell is delightful! :)

I recently purchased this and it came in and they were too small. Ordering a .5 size up! Hopefully they will fit. Otherwise great texture. LOVE THE SMELL. sturdy.

Shipping was SO FAST! The boots are well made and a great investment piece. I order a size 9 wide calf even though I've never had to buy a wide calf before. But due to reviews I went wide just in case - the wides are still too tight! But I was prepared for this and used leather conditioner and a hair dryer to stretch them out a bit - which was super easy and I'm very happy with my purchase.

Oh Melissa Button 2, how I wanted to spend a lifetime with you. These boots were stunning out of the box. Everything I wanted. The rich leather look and smell, the quality construction and attention to detail, the dark redwood color. We were destined to spend many years together. But alas, some relationships just don't work out. I had a really, really hard time getting these on (and I grew up on a farm where we wore cowboy boots that needed a boot jack to remove). The only way I could get them on was with super thin or no socks, which sort of defeats the purpose of a boot. If I'd gone up a size, they would have been too long. The only thing I can figure out is my metatarsal/tarsal joint over my arch (yeah I had to look that up) sits particularly high which makes the whole pointed foot maneuver tougher to get into boots (and that part of my foot gets irritated by a lot of shoes so I know it sits high). Once I got them on, the seam near the ankle rubbed my ankle and that would just bug me. I don't think it was a break-in period kind of fix. Oh, I have smaller calves so it's hard for tall boots not to do the big boot gap thing. These had a little bit of gap on me at the top, but they still looked great. It was a deliberate style gap that will work. Anyway, if these fit your foot, they are stunning and quality beauties. I wish you the best in your relationship!