Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

These were super cute, super comfy boots but they weren’t red like the photo, more of a burgundy so I am returning them,

Listen up fam, these boots are amazing! I’m a size 12 and can NEVER find shoes that fit, are comfortable and cute but these checked all the boxes. They fit me perfectly with a little wiggle room for my toes. They are the dream stylish snow boot and are going to be perfect for city life.

Wore them for the first time today after the most recent post Thanksgiving blizzard. I utilize 3/4 custom orthotics, and the boots are very comfortable with them inserted. There is no arch support without them. The boots are also lightweight, which is a plus if you plan to wear them for long periods of time, and are very warm even without thick wool socks. The drawback to these boots is that they are very slippery in icy, snowy weather. For example, if your city or town or campus has not done a great job salting after clearing snow and ice remains in patches on the ground, you are in trouble. I left work early today to avoid the freeze after sundown, after having to walk extra gingerly into the office this morning. Someone said you have to scuff up the bottoms, but they still have little to no traction. Maybe as time wears on.

I really wanted to like these boots as the price is amazing but they are too big and clunky and they squeak.

These are super cute, but I'm looking for a cute "warm" boot that I can trek through snow. These have laces and I can imagine snow getting inside. And they don't feel very warm nor do they feel very comfortable to walk in (not much padding on the sole). Unfortunately, I am going to return them.

I bought a pair of these last year and they are the best snow boot I have ever owned. They keep my feet warm and dry. Unfortunately, my husband gave them to a friend by mistake. She loves them, so I ordered another pair for this season, hoping that they will be staying with me a long time. :-)

Very stylish, but I bought them as snow boots. They weather was 14 degrees and my feet were freezing. I had very think boot socks and I had to purchase additional pair of socks. It wasn’t snowing it was just cold in New York. Has little or no support but my inserts fit fine. I ordered 1/2 size larger to be able to add inserts and thick socks. Overall they are comfortable but not warm and toasty.

Fit and size perfect. Very lightweight and comfortable. Waterproof was a must since they are to be worn in snow and rain.

Love these for the snow and look cute too

I haven't worn these outside yet, but they feel great on my feet. I got 1/2 size bigger because I want to have room for big, warm socks. So far, so good.

I am usually size 9 but with winter boots I go up to 9.5 to accommodate thicker socks. I love the look of this boot and while I have not worn them yet I have full confidence they will be wonderful. I will be using them in Iceland in December and will update this review if they fail to perform.

Love Columbia! Fit is good. Went up 1/2 size so I could wear heavier sox. Price was right.

I purchased these boots three years ago and only now need to replace them.

I love these boots. Got the elk/red velvet, nice color with jeans. They are cute and comfortable, easy to get on and off, and top is wide enough for any pant leg.

Great snow shoes! These are light weight and have excellent traction. The lace up ties allow for easy on/off as well as adjusting how tight you would like the boots.

Love these boots so far! I only live in the Pacific Northwest, not a deep-freeze region, but still, my feet have a way of getting miserably chilly in winter even in "warm" boots, so I ordered the Ice Maidens with the hope that FINALLY they'd be warm enough. And they have been so far! Walked a couple of miles in the chilly November rain today, and my feet stayed dry and comfortable. No blisters or sore places either. Plus they look rather stylish in my opinion. Keepers!

The shoe fit well in length and width. The right boot was perfect. The left boot dig into my ankle. The back support piece was so stiff it pushed through the lining and caused sharp pain. I have to send them back as I can’t walk in them

Love these boots! This is my third pair of Columbia and I would not buy any other brand in winter boots! I bought the Cordovan and love the color. I do normally wear an 8 1/2 but sized up to a 9 so I could wear heavier sox.` The price is right so don't hesitate to buy these!

I love these boots! I’ve been waiting to find just the right pair of winter boots and I think I struck gold! Now just need some snow!

So glad I decided to purchase these boots. Their stylish and comfortable, love them. Order size 6 perfect fit, and warm. Can’t wait to test them out on the snow.

Very cute and comfortable boots. I sent them back because there is sewing on the inside where the tabs for laces are, one of them had a very thick spot and it pushed on the bridge of my foot and left a red sore mark when I took them off. I will reorder this pair.

Loooove them. Was worried about them fitting under jeans, but they do fine under boot-cut jeans. I have crappy ankles and having the lace-up high support on the winter snow and ice is lovely. Super comfy. Nice looking enough that I feel that if I were to wear a skirt or dress (!!) then I could still wear them and it wouldn't look too weird.

The boots seems like it will last a long time. They are very comfortbale and super warm.

These boots are cute, yet sporty and comfortable. Actually looking forward to more inclement weather so I can wear them more

I got these in the shale/raspberry. The color is mostly dark grey but the fabric part has a VERY SLIGHT dark pinkish hue. They were cute, but I returned them and am waiting for my size in the brown which will work better for me. These boots come up to mid calf - I was hoping for a slightly taller boot, but you can't beat the price and they seemed really warm.