Customer Reviews Florsheim Castellano Wingtip Oxford

The color was completely different from the picture shown online.

i used it hardly for 3 weeks, the right sole torn apart in 2 pieces, i wish i could add a photograph here

Flaws in shoes resulted in TWO separate replacement orders, the last of which still had defects. First pair had a large glue blotch and a misalignment between sole colors at the side. Second pair had a large white glue blotch in the broguing. Third pair now had large glue blotch on the side of the some of the shoe and leather quality seemed low compared to other two sets sent (small wrinkles, leather already felt quite soft). I finally gave up and am sending the last pair back. VERY disappointed in the lack of quality control. Will still buy Florsheim shoes but NOT bothering to do so online, as you aren't thorough about what you send out. At least in a shoe store the quality of your shoes is still good, others likely inspected them when stocking them, and I can inspect them before purchasing. Just fed up with the internet ordering...

I think these are made out of plastic. I didn’t even try them on.

Did not look like picture. On the website, they look like distressed leather, which was what I wanted. The actual shoes look terrible — like plastic

You got a one rating but I would of given it a zero

VERY DISAPPOINTED WITH SHOW. OUT WEDDING PARTY WANTED TO PURCHASE THE SHOES FOR THE GROOMSMEN FOR A WEDDING IS SEPTEMBER 2017. EVERYONE REMARKED, THE SHOES LOOK CHEAP AND LOOK LIKE THEY WERE MADE FROM PLASTIC. SHOE WAS SENT BACK SOMETIME AGO, WAITING FOR A CONFIRMATION.

These shoes are awful. For 100+dollar price point the shoe is essentially patent leather or vinyl. The finish is very dull and the shoe is comparable to a mall department store clearance rack shoe. I did not try the shoe on... called zappos and ordered a pair of Johnston Murphys. I was not expecting a pair of Allen edmonds or even JM but these shoes did nothing but disappoint.

The product showed up with the sole split. It looks like a poorly repairs factory second.

Thes shoes were returned vis UPS and delivered 12/16/15 and signed for by Miller, and I requested that they be replaced one size smaller i.e. 12. I have no communication, or notification since, nor has my money been refunded. What is going on?

These shoes are super narrow. I have worn florshiem in the past with a size 9 normal width. But these shoes would be the first shoes that I wold buy extra wide.

The show does not look anything like it does in the picture. I needed a dress show and this was more of a casual offering.

I have been wearing Florsheim shoes for more than a decade for the simple reasons that I could afford them, they fit, and they were professional looking. My first pair lasted about 6 years, they were perfect, picked them up for $50 locally, wore them every day. My second pair cost about $150 and were special order, but they were calfskin, and of equivalent quality, that was 5 years ago. I thought I overpaid but I still have and wear them. I purchased from the Imperial line last year, they were cheap, corrected leather, nearly $200, and are already wore out after occasional formalwear use. But they still fit. Enter these: I knew they would be cheap but for the money, if they fit, they would be worth it. They do not fit. I have ALWAYS wore the exact same size, but buying these in that size resulted in a left shoe that was almost an inch too long and a right that was an inch and a half too long with at least an inch of extra width in the heel. What? You say, an inch? Yes, an inch, I line them up next to my old shoes and they are that much longer and they aren't even the same size to each other! The lining is peeling away from the outer, the sole has odd lumps on the outside and inside, this is not true Full-grain leather (contrary to the description), it is obviously corrected, and the burnishing looks like smeared sharpie. Maybe QC just missed this pair, but after the last pair wearing out after less than 20 wears, I'm not going to take that chance, and neither should you. Florsheim just lost a decade of loyalty in less than two years.