Customer Reviews Florsheim Castellano Wingtip Oxford

I wish Florsheim could finally fix their size issues. Most of their shoes are either small to the size or too large.

Bought both black and brown. The black upper squeaks when I walk. Returned for another pair and they squeaked too. The brown are fine. Must be in the tanning of the black.

I was very disappointed at how the material of the shoe cracked. After one wear, the shoe looks like I've worn it for years.

I bought these shoes - in the 2018 model - when they were on sale this spring based upon a recommendation from a trusted friend. While I like the way the shoes look and fit, I was disgusted when I took them off today and saw that the soles were cracked completely throughout in multiple spots. I have worn them AT MOST 7 times, and this is the result. Clearly, the shoes started to crack even before today, which means the shoes have a longevity of about 5 wears. Florshiem shoes, this is unacceptable. I am at least fortunate that I bought them at a time they were on 50% sale because I would be even more livid if I had bought them at the $100+ listing. I will never trust this brand again, friend's recommendation or not. I will leave this review on all wingtip/oxford Florsheim shoes because it is ridiculous that they are trying to sell such a low quality product to people for such a high price.

Florsheim must have changed their supplier. I bought this same shoe a couple of years ago and it is my favorite shoe. I wore it out and decided to order the same exact shoe. The "new" leather looks really cheap compared to the previous leather. I will not be wearing the new one. Even though I never even tried the shoe on I'm past the 30 day return policy. Lesson learned I will not be buying online from Florsheim again

Shoes squeezeaked when I walked had to return them.

Cheap shoes. Uncomfortable and the sizing of the shoes is completely wrong and doenst match the size chart. I orded size 11.5, which the shoes were labeled as when i took them out of the box and they we the same size as my brothers size 13 shoes. I had to wear them in a wedding the same week they arrived and didn't have time to order a different pair. The size chart said that inside of the 11.5 should of been 11 and a 1/2 inches and they were actially 12 and 1/2 inches. Do yourself a favor and just leave this website and look for a different brand.

The color on the website ad: cognac. The color of the picture on the box: cognac. the color of the shoes represented by the website and the box: light tan.

I purchased the brown color shoe. The leather has a cheap plastic/shiny look. Immediately afer taking a few steps inside my home to try them out, the leather upper started cracking, and the cracks look very light because the coating comes right off. I own a pair of the Saddle Brown and never had this issue, although the soles are thin and cheap on both pairs. Perhaps they lowered the quality to save on production costs. I hate to say it, but many of these modern day Florsheims seem to be a cheap imitation of the originals that earned them a good name in the eyes of our society. Very disappointed, as I was really looking forward to these shoes. I will be sending back for a refund and looking elsewhere for my next pair. Florsheim, please step up your game, and stop ripping people off with inferior products advertised as the quality products your company offered when they originated. My faith in you is quickly dissipating.

The sole cracked on both shoes the first time I wore them

Such a shame. The outsole cracked in the very first day of use.