Customer Reviews Florsheim Castellano Wingtip Oxford

I have the cognac. Great looking shoe but the heel is not flat to the ground. There's an unbalance causing an awkward and uncomfortable feel when walking. The dye inside the shoe has ruined several of my socks. It's a bit embarrassing to take my shoes off and have brown stains all over my socks. I have the same style cap toe and it's great, no issues whatsoever. It could be just this particular shoe though. It does have some faults.

When I ordered the shoes the price was the same as a previous order. Therefore I thought it was the same quality and style. Wrong. It was of cheaper quality.

I had previously owned two pairs of Florsheim shoes that each lasted four years (with a new sole replacement on each) but the leather was great and did not stain. This pair I recently purchased has cheap feeling leather and soles.

I used to work in a leather shop, these days I don't like to use leather [BUT] when I buy leather, I really look for quality. I returned these shoes bc they felt really flimsy and weak. The stitching on the leather was also weak. The shoes didn't seem like they would last more than a year. In addtn, they are not even oxfords, I thought this would be okay as I liked the look of the design, but it's actually a derby shoe. Ox has closed lacing, not open.

They didn't last 3 weeks and I weigh less than 200 lbs. The soles fractured, one heel came loose. My sox would get wet just walking across wet pavement, the edge of one sole cracked at the edge of the shoe and the soles of both were cracked all of the way through every inch or so. I 've owned 15 pairs of Florsheims over the years and these shoes are now the worst pair of any brand I have owned in my life.......

My husband just texted me pictures of the bottoms of these shoes. He's worn them 4, maybe 5 times since received. The entire sole is cracking, flaking and falling apart. Pictures provided. Please note the almost new condition of these shoes - the stitching on the sole is clean & not worn at all. So disappointed in this purchase.

Bought these for my wedding day. Upon receiving shoes I noticed a small crack on the underside of the sole. Sent a picture and email to Florsheim about it and told them it was too late for me to change them out and so I had to wear them. By the time the wedding was over, the undersides were completely cracked and falling apart. I've worn these for one day! Still waiting to hear back about returning, really hoping these were just defective because they look awesome and I've always heard good things about the company. However, after reading through these reviews I'm far from the only one to have this issue.

Soles started cracking/chipping and discoloration on shoe. Really disappointed!

I won't buy these ever again. I bought them for my wedding and one pair literally fell apart and the others looked trashed at the end of the night. They won't even last a day with normal walking and dancing. You can get better shoes for the same price elsewhere that will last

I ordered size 11D which is my regular size. I received the shoe and it felt like 12D. Returned for 10.5D and they don't have my size. Refunded.

Was not the same product as the picture, the shoes were way lighter then shown on the picture

Horrible quality, upon loosening the shoelaces to try on the shoes for the first time....I flexed the sole and it cracked across the entire sole!!!!!!!! I did not even get the chance to put my foot in them. I will be returning and will not order from Florsheim in the future. Extremely disappointed.

These shoes weren't even close to the color they were supposed to be, not close,, be aware the entire shoe was brown, no fading from the toe back. And the opening where your foot goes in is wider than any other dress shoes and when I walk on cement I get pebbles (rocks) in my shoes constantly. BUY COLE HAAN

Severely disappointed by this purchase. This would have been my third pair of Florsheims in a row. When I put the shoes on for the first time, I noted cracking sounds when I made my first steps. I wore the shoes for a day and when I took them off I saw that the soles of the shoes were cracked/split all the way through. One day!!! Given that I have had great experiences with the first two pairs I owned this may have been a manufacturing defect. These are being returned and I am requesting a full refund. The returns process was a good one. (Thanks for using UPS).