Customer Reviews Florsheim Castellano Wingtip Oxford

Great shoe! stylish with a slightly euro flair but nothing over the top (does not have that long "wizard toe" pointy thing going on which I hate). Nice color on heal. Looks great with jeans or suit. Pretty comfortable too, 4 stars for everything because nothing is perfect!

Typically I wear a 14 in shoes that run large and a 13 in shoes that run small. After reading the reviews and finding that most said they run large, I ordered a 13. Forget running large, however, they are practically sized incorrectly. The 13 was almost falling off my foot! After returning them for a 12, they fit well and I am very pleased with the shoes!

Runs big. Seems to be pretty stiff, but will be nice once they're broken in. Moderately comfortable for dress shoes.

Beware: runs a full size larger. Knocked it down a star because I had to return for the correct size. I normally have to buy a 13, as I'm a 12.5. With the comments that the shoe runs large, I ordered a 12. The 12 is still too large and I had to order an 11.5.

The shoe felt much larger than the sizing. I got a 10.5 and it felt more like an 11.5. I compared it to my other 10.5 size shoes and it was definitely longer. The darker coloring on the toe and heel is much more prominent in real life than on the image. I won't knock the star rating down because of that though because it's all based on your own preference and the style you are going for. I would suggest getting a half size smaller than what you usually get for this shoe.

This is a beautiful, high-quality shoe. However, it's enormous! I ordered my normal size and it felt almost a full size longer (I normally wear Cole-Haan dress shoes). Made me wonder if it was mis-marked. It's also very high (measured from the ground to the top of the shoe). The top parts that lace together were almost touching on my shoe. This means you might want to consider a bit narrower than you normally wear. As always, Zappos exchange was a piece of cake.

The sole is quite stiff so, when you step, the shoe folds behind the toe and pinches your foot. Not only is this uncomfortable, but make the shoe look cheap. The size was a little larger than expected. I typically wear a 9.5, but this definitely feels like a 10.

The fit was good and the design looks cool. However, the "wing tip" portion of the left foot wasn't centered, and would have driven me crazy, so I sent them back. They scuffed easily and I imagine the two-tone would be a nightmare to have to polish the scuffs out.

Too narrow so I ordered the wide and it was too wide. Returned both.

Too narrow for me.

The color was absolutely off from the photos online. Looked and felt like it was made of cheap materials and the darkened toe tip was spray painted on.