Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Paulette

I have 10 1/2 W feet, but ordered a size down and these shoes were still too big on me. I kept them just because I have such a hard time fitting into shoes and needed a navy pair right away. The leather is a little stiff, but I hope that goes away.

Over all very comfortable, but I have narrow feet with 8A heels and my heel kept popping out of the shoe, even with socks!

I have a high arch and a wide foot. These shoes appeared to be large and wide enough, but I couldn't get my foot in because the closing was too high and too tight. I can't actually provide any information on the size, width, comfort or anything else since I couldn't get my foot into it.

5.5 was way too big; will return and look for another similar style shoe.

Like the look. Would be a good run-around shoe, but the toe box did not accommodate my hammertoe. The Aravon Faith was much more comfortable

Very small toe box, otherwise nice looking shoe.

I like the look of these shoes and they seem to have good support but my heel slipped in them so I had to return them.

Like all Cobb Hill shoes I own, this shoe is divinely comfortable. It looks a bit old-ladyish, but since I'm an old lady, it all makes perfect sense. If you're looking for a comfortable, nice-looking closed-top shoe, this is the one.

This shoe has a lot of great detail. The leather is soft and it is a lovely shade of dark red. Unfortunately,I have difficult feet to fit-bunions, arthritis, crooked toes and narrow heels. I usually wear a 5.5. These felt larger and the heel moved up and down as I walked. It was just the style I was looking. But they are just too big.

Love this shoe, but sadly it is too long. I'm going to try the next half size down! It felt comfortable and roomy.

This navy shoe was very comfortable, but too loose in the heel for me. It also seemed to run about a half size large. I ordered a 9.5 narrow and it was too big overall, even with trouser socks. Have ordered a 9 narrow and am hoping it will fit.

The shoes are very comfortable to walk in and provide excellent arch support. I would recommend these shoes.

Comfortable and stylish. Not supportive enough for long walks, but fine for everything else.

I love this shoes, they are a little on the narrow side but I think they will stretch a little with use and then they will be perfect. Very cute shoes though.

This shoe is extremely comfortable, and much cuter on than I thought. However, the description says it has a removable footbed, and i disagree. The foot bed could be removed, but it was glued n at one spot pretty firmly. I knew that if I took the foot bed out to try my orthotics in the shoe, then I would have damaged the shoe and would not be able to return it. I decided to take the risk, and was glad I did, but I would not list this as a removable foot bed. I have wide feet, and need to have a shoe that will take orthotics. These are as scare as hens teeth. I am gratefulto have found something that will work for me.

Excellent all-around shoe for work. They are lightweight and have good cushioning, but I wish they had more arch support. I especially like how this shoe fits wide feet comfortably, but still looks rather stylish and not too clunky. The traction on the rubber souls is a nice bonus.

Very comfortable, but the heel keeps slipping off. I think I should have ordered a half size smaller.

This shoe fits in length and width but the heel box is too wide. There was a visible gap on both sides but the gap on the right shoe was larger (large enough to stick my little finger in the gap). The style looks better in the photos than on the foot.

I have had these since last year and worn them on average 2x per week since then. They are very comfortable - which is my number one concern. The style is ok or at least not horrid. I don't feel particularly fashionable when I wear them but I don't hide my feet. My biggest complaint is the grey part of the sole is coming off so I can't give these marks on longevity.

Nice casual shoe, elastic across top of shoe a bit tight but should loosen with wear. Generally happy with Cobb Hill brand.

I like these shoes a lot. They have plenty of toe room (which is important to me because in the winter, my toes get really irritated for some mystery reason). I like the way they look as well. The only negative for me (that other reviewers have also reported) is that the heel is just a bit too wide. Even with thick socks, my foot comes out of the shoe. But because of the elastic across the top, the shoe stays on, so I am keeping them. It almost feels like a backless shoe, so it seems to work okay. I do wish they were a little more snug in the heel though.

Cobb Hill shoes are comfortable, amen! But they are not chic, cool, or stylish. My feet are such a mess that sometimes I just have to buy Cobb Hill.

I'm bummed. too narrow, even the W. My first Cobb Hill shoes were too wide, but I guess that was a fluke.