Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

Not that impressed. Returning for Frye Melissa back zip boot. Once you go Frye, nothing else will do. I'd rather have a higher quality boot I can wear for years than trying to save a few bucks and only wear for a season. Pass for me.

These boats make my feet look like boats, they make my calves look shapeless and pencil-like, and they make my thighs looks monstrous! Not flattering at all! These babies are going back right away! I suppose this boot would look good on someone with small feet, long lower leg, and skinny thighs. on the plus side they are comfortable!

Cheap looking leather. The shaft circumference was too big for my 13" calves. Eh!

Loved these boots - only sorry I had to return them. They seemed to run 1/2 size too small - the back zip was too close for comfort to my heel. The leather is super soft/ supple. But this lends it to scrunch on the front of the foot. Sad to say - have to send it back.

Too Big ! I could get boyh feet and legs in one.

The boots looked very sturdy. The foot was okay but small. As for the leather, I was very disappointed because they looked kind of wrinkly… not straight and stand up like a great quality leather.

I ordered the correct size by could not get my foot in these boots. I have a high arch and my sister tried them on and she has flat feet. She couldn't get into them either. We confirmed the size that was ordered. This boot got such a good review. I'm so disappointed. They are lovely boots.

The foot sizing is great, but WHY does a size 9M boot have such a HUGE calf shaft - and so short?!? It fits like a Wide in the calf - it's at least twice as wide. If they offered this in a true narrow shaft, it would fit great. I'm 5'9", athletic, with long, toned, and slender legs. The shaft is too short for a "riding boot" style. I love the detailing, leather quality, and zipper placement on the back without a seam in front, but it is a boot made for shorter women with much bigger calves. Returning, very disappointed.

These went back. Boots just weren’t comfortable. I think Sorel spoiled me with their comfortable out of the box boots.

The one boot calf Was much smaller. I couldn’t zip it up so I have to return.

This was a W but couldn't even get my foot in.

This looks cheap. The leather is not high quality, and the color makes it look like plastic.

Ordered the boot twice, the 1st time the boots fit a little small. Reordered the boots and they sent boots that looked nothing like the pictures or the 1st pair of boots shipped. Very disappointed, with how it played out.

These just arrived and I couldn’t even get them zipped up. The boot is so narrow and very tight. I’m really disappointed. Sending back