Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

bought these for my wife and they look great. She was pleased with the fit and comfort. We live out in the sticks and were amazed with the one day free shipping. I have trouble finding shoes that fit in stores due to my small feet but zappos has been a great find for me.

Slightly small; can’t wear chunky socks with these boots. Otherwise, they are beautiful. I’m glad I bought them & I would highly recommend them.

Based on other reviews, I was pretty nervous about how these boots would fit, but I really wanted to try them out. I normally wear a 10, sometimes need a 10.5 but since they are hard to find, I usually go with a 10. I have never bought wide shoes before but I don’t have narrow feet. Size 10.5 wasn’t available, so I decided to go with a 10W based on other reviews. Much to my surprise, they fit like a glove! They are comfortable and just right. Very beautiful boots.

I think this riding boot is such a great value for a genuine leather boot, especially when you compare to other brands in similar styles. The leather is soft (not sure yet on durability because they're new), the fit is true to size, and I love that there is traction on the bottom (also an advantage over the pricier competitor). I would definitely recommend this boot to anyone looking for a nice, stylish boot! I ordered the black, and love the color!

Love and would purchase again

I bought these boots two years ago and I’m about to buy another pair right now. I’m a bartender and am on my feet constantly and after two years they’ve finally started cracking on the soles. Which is amazing for me! I wear through shoes so fast. They’re also comfortable. They look great. I really love these boots and will buy them again and again.

I LOVE these. However, the wide size still pinched my toes in front. not a lot of flexibility in the toe. had to return

Beautiful leather, classic style but I can’t comfortably zip them with leggings or skinny jeans so back they go. My calf measurement is borderline @ 15.5 “ but I had to try!

I love these. But I have to return them for a wide width. I've never worn a wide. Unless you have narrow feet you might want to start with a wide.

Very comfortable boots!

These boots were a gift for my daughter and she absolutely loved them

Love these boots! Wear them all fall and winter. Comfy and stylish. Am going to order them in brown too!

Great looking boots. Stylish yet comfortable!

Very nice looking boot, but absolutely NOT wide in any way shape or form!

I love this boot! The leather is soft and holds up well to a busy momma lifestyle. I ordered a 6.5 to allow room for socks and it fit nicely... I usually wear a 6. I’ve had them for two fall/winter seasons and they still look great and the sole has worn well.

These boots are made well. I loved them so much I bought them in brown and in black. Definitely worth the price!

Beautiful boots for the price.

I really loved these boots. They're a gorgeous color and the footbed is comfortable. Unfortunately, they were very large in the calf. I have a 14.5 inch calf and they were swimming in this shaft. So, I'm returning... but I know they will be a good fit for many.

These are the cutest riding boots! They look adorable with dresses/skirts or jeans. I wear them often and always get compliments.

Great boots. Love Zappos!! Never buy foot wear any where else. Unfortunately, I ordered wrong size twice but they are always supportive.

I have been waiting for these boots. They are worth every penny. They make cold, snowy winters warm and cute! I should have bought them sooner!

I am 5' 0" tall and I was very excited to read reviews by other petite women describing how well these boots fit. However, when these boots arrived, I found that they come to the middle of my knee cap and did not look good at all. These boots are beautiful but I am really disappointed in the fit. If anyone out there has other recommendations for boots for petite women I'd love to hear them.

The foot of the boot fits really well for a narrow foot like mine. However, the calf area is still baggie-a problem I have had no luck solving. The leather is awesome and the zip up the back makes the fit really nice.

More like a caramel color.

These boots are beautiful. I wanted some new boots for New York and am hard to fit. These came in my size and looked great, so I tried them. Wore them out of the box with no problem. Insoles are not removable, but I used my orthotics anyway, and had no difficulties. The color is luscious and the darkened accents are classy. My only complaint is that the little snap over the top of the zipper in the back unsnaps every time I uncross my legs. Maybe it will help me learn to stop crossing my legs!!