Customer Reviews Comfortiva Posie - Soft Spots

These shoes look very nice for an office environment. They are also very comfortable. If you have big feet (like me with a size 11), they don't fully cover your toes on the top. They also seem a little big, but maybe my feet are really 10.5 and nobody sells 10.5. They also seem a good value for the money.

I wish these covered my foot just a bit more on the top. The opening edge rubs on the top of the ball of my foot. Other than that they are cute and have moderate cushioning.

These were cute shoes and looked like they would last but they are significantly smaller than normal sizing.

I loved the look and the feel. Unfortunately they were too wide and I couldn't keep them on my feet.

Scuffs easily

The inside sole has contouring that feels odd on my feet. Can't decide whether to keep the shoes or not. Thinking the contouring will deflate as I wear them, and be less of an issue, but worried that the contouring will cause hot spots on my feet. Hmmmmm.

The shoe is marked as wide. However, it is not a wide width. When comparing the sole with a shoe I own, it is almost a half inch narrower than what I have that is marked as regular relaxed.

Hits big toe joint, so too uncomfortable to wear.

Comfortable and cute but wears out much too fast. It took one walk in my backyard and the leather got worn off in multiple places, after less than a couple months.

Just too tight.

The toe box is so short and narrow,that my ties were way to tight. Could not even walk in them.

For some reason, these were so small that it just doesn't make sense. My usual size is 9. They was so tight I couldn't even get them on my feet, so I returned them. I assumed the 9 1/2 would fit, so I just grabbed the box as soon as they arrived and ran out the door, with the idea that I would change into them after my commute. That was such a bad idea because I had to wear them at work even the 9 1/2 is so tight I can barely get them over my heel. Now I am stuck with a cute pair of shoes that are impossible to wear.

Cute, casual shoe but felt too tight in the toe box.

Before Covid, these were my go-to work shoes. They were really great for my bunion and so cushion-y! Now that I'm back in the office full time, I needed new shoes to replace the 2019 ones that I had. These are not the same shoes. :( The leather seems more flimsy (as others mentioned) and liable to tear if going up stairs, not being careful while driving (stepping on gas/break pedals), etc. Also, there is very minimal cushion. After wearing this pair and a brown pair that I ordered around the same time, my feet are screaming. I have to have arch and good support - these do not deliver. I'm very sad as I've recommended them to many other people in the past, but I will be ordering a different brand now. Hope my feet feel better in other shoes.

I think these would have worked for me but the toe box was cramped. I ordered 7.5WW. Unfortunately, I am returning them. The hunt for shoes continues.

These shoes were exactly what I was looking for, but I had to return. They were too big (but not big enough to size up). I put the pad in the back to stop me feet from slipping out, but there was not enough room in the front for my toes. They were all squished together and it was very uncomfortable. Very cute otherwise, but just didn't fit my feet. Back to the drawing board!

Cute shoe, however I can’t speak to the comfort due to the small fit. Shoe seemed a whole shoe size short in the toe box & heel. Width seemed true.

This shoe was not wide enough. I ordered the extra wide but it was tight across my bunion.

Trotters style is usually attractive, but it's seems impossible to find a W or WW shoe that fits in the forefoot, has a big enough toe box, but doesn't slip up/down on the heel. This style was also cut so low, toward the toes, that the shoe wasn't comfortable. Sadly had to return.

I really wanted to like this shoe. It is very pretty, and I thought it would fit the occasion I needed it for. Unfortunately, the toe box was extremely narrow; and, after wearing it around the house for a couple of hours, it had rubbed blisters already. So, sadly, I had to return it.

Runs smaller and narrower

A great looking shoe-just way too tight in the toe box, despite ordering a wide. I had hoped that with a wide there would be more room.

Ordered this shoe and liked the look and the softness of the lining. BUT, I wear a 6.5 M and the shoe was extremely small, perhaps because of the cushiony lining. Probably would have to order at least a 7.5 to fit. Will be returning these. I should have read some of the reviews, as that seems to be a common complaint for this particular style.

Way too small!

I ordered a wide and that part seemed to fit well, but the toe box was so low that my large toe nail was under pressure all the time. Had to return.