Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Looks good on but too stiff and uncomfortable for me.

interesting fit. Heel height is good. Quite narrow in the toe box- even for a "narrow" foot. Something about the arch or instep or something undefinable that makes it just not fit my foot correctly. Not much cushion. Cute boot though & nice leather. Thanks to Zappos!!!!

I'll be returning this shoe. Ordered a wide, but rubbed on my bunion. Sole feels stiff. Heel swims in too wide space. Think I'll stick with softwalk Rocklin graphit boot instead.

These are really comfortable, however, the soles at the ends started chipping off and the white plastic type material is quite visible. I still like them cause of the comfort.

Super cute and stylish. Love the color but shoe is much pointier than I expected and has too much room in the heel. Slips when I try to walk and rubs the sides of my heels. Returning.

This is a beautiful taupe. narrow across ball of foot and top of foot.

too narrow ball of foot. Petty is a great grey.

I fell in love with the Putty boots and went back and order the saddle. I went a half size down per my true to size shoes. I didn't have to break in the shoes just like the Putty version. It was comfortable and easy to walk in. I though the heel with perfect enough to add a bit of femininity to the boots without looking like it's over the top. I wear a size 8 and ordered a 7.5. It fits fine but with this socks on. My feet are not narrow or wide, it's in between.

Really, really cute and a great quality but even in a wide the toe seems to run narrow and there is absolutely no tread on the bottom. I loved them but they're way too slippery for me to feel comfortable walking around in them.

I really wanted to love these boots because of all the great reviews... but it was too wide on my ankles. They looked awkward on me when I tried it on with a skirt. They were comfortable but had to return them.

This shoe isn't that comfortable, and does not run true to size. I am a solid 6, and I could hardly zip these up. I only had thin socks on too. I'd probably have to order a 7 to fit, but hey aren't very comfortable compared to other brands I've shopped.

The toe box is big and round kinda odd looking. The boot is very stiff.

I've been searching for a just-right short gray bootie for a long time. Unfortunately, this was not the one. I like the dark gray color, the black sole, and the heel height. But the boot seems to run narrow, it's difficult to put on, it has little to no padding and arch support on the insole, and the the outsole is very stiff.

Beautiful boot. Boots looked like they were tried on multiple times and the back part of the heel along the seam was worn looking. My foot slipped a lot in the heel when I walked. Sending back to get something similar.

Smart, fashionable pair of boots. Excellent material. Adds elegance to the wearer. Boots half size larger and wider, extremely uncomfortable, especially for walking. Too tough. Would have loved a pair that would give comfort in terms of fit and warmth especially in the winter time. This is a pair that does not hug snugly one's feet.

Very uncomfortable, too much of a pointed toe for me, found a better value somewhere else on a similar bootie

I wish I had liked these but even with the wide width my left foot felt some uncomfortable constriction. For weather in Wisco though I think they might need something with more of a grip on the bottom. Its a hard smooth surface so I just know I would wipe out somewhere with them if they had fit. I would have probably taken them to the cobbler to have something put on the bottoms to make them more practical for me. Wish they fit better...back on the hunt I go!

Very smart looking pair of booties. It gave elegance to whoever wears it with its make and style. Would have given it 5 stars, but it is so stiff and extremely difficult to put on because of its zipper location (one zip on one side). Also, sizing is half a size bigger. I did not realize it was half a size bigger until I started wearing it. Inside, my feet would slide, but it felt ok when I tried it on. Wpuld have returned it, but I already used it. I needed to glue an insole to make the booties usable. I really regret having spent so much money on this pair and not be happy about it. It seems the pair will just be sittingg in my shoe closet. Time to look for a better fitting pair of bootie.

I had read that these were among the most comfortable boots. Nothing could be further from the truth for me. They are beautiful to look at, but for me it ended there. The insole has absolutely no cushioning, and they run narrow. So sad they didn't work out!

I bought this bootie in the black and think it's a great shoe with a good not-so-pointed toe. However, I agree with others that one shoe feels slightly bigger than the other, which is a manufacturing error, not a Zappos complaint. I really couldn't decide between the regular width or wide width and am glad of Zappos generous return policy. I ended up with the wider width because I'll probably wear low cut athletic socks anyway. While there were other booties that were similar, the toe looked to pointed or "motorcycle babe" for me. Thanks for working with me on this Zappos!

The color is a little "off" in the picture it looks rich brown, mine was old mustard. The middle part of boot was too wide and would only stretch more. I have med. width foot. Other than those negatives it would be very comfortable out of the box.

I read multiple reviews on this boot. Most of the reviews indicated that the boot runs narrow. With that in mind, I ordered wide width. The wide width boot was too narrow.

The leather is very stiff, and they are not really very wide , even though that is what I ordered. The suede is a bit more forgiving so i am keeping those.the leather is not very pretty either.

I really wanted to like this shoe but it wasn't for me. First off, I usually wear a 9 but in this shoe it was just too big on me. I also wasn't crazy on how the style look on me. However, it does seem like a well made shoe and felt comfortable even though it was too big on me.

footbed hard and not comfortable. They look great but just not comfortable.