Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Really nice looking boot. I really wanted these to fit, but, alas, just too tight. Got a 9W, wish the Petty came in a WW.

I think this boot either fits great or not at all. The size seems correct but the width was odd for me, wide enough at the toes but narrow across the middle of the foot. I purchased a 9.5 medium width and returned them. After reading more reviews I don’t believe going up a size or to a wide width would work for me. I do not have a high arch and have not run into a fit like this.

Gosh! Couldn't even get my foot into the boot to try them on fully. Truly a disappointment. I don't usually buy wide width footwear but I guess I would have to for this boot. Nice looking, color looks true and appears well made for you who have thin feet!

Love the look of these boots and very happy with the comfort level. Only issue is that, when I received them, the heel of one boot appeared to be starting to separate from the sole a bit. I didn't want to deal with returning/rebuying, so I tried to fix it with some superglue, which seems to have worked. Very strange since I own many pairs of Sam Edelman shoes and have never had quality issues in the past.

I have a high arch and these didn't offer support and weren't very comfortable.

Ordered two different colors, loved them both, fit was fine, but these are so incredibly slippery, even on carpeted floors, I struggled to walk across the room after I tried on for the first time. Going back for that reason only, and that's a shame.

I have a fairly narrow foot (my father used to special order narrow running shoes) and these shoes are crazy narrow. Not comfortable because of narrow footbed and they are loose through the ankle so rub with every step. Going back.

I just got them and will be returning them. They look nice for sure (moss green-really just a nice shade of brown) but they are too tight (I ordered them in wide) and have zero arch support. I do have high arches and am used to wearing Danskos and Birkenstocks which have incredible arch support so these will not work at all for me.

These boots are great, but I could barely get them on my feet. I wore them with socks for a while one evening, hoping they would stretch out, but when my toes started falling asleep, I knew they'd have to go back. I ordered a full size larger, hoping that they will fit.

Cute, but so stiff I couldn't get them on without gymnastics. Returning.

had to return because the wide was too narrow. The sole has no cushion and seemed like it would be slippery.

Although super cute, these booties felt stiff and tight when first putting them on. I could tell they were not going to comfortable in the long run, so opted to return them.

Loved the look of the boot but it was difficult to get my foot into . I think I need a wider toe box and more support. Will try the Dansko

So beautiful but who are they kidding? I ordered 7 1/2 Wide to accommodate my high arch Cannot even get my foot into the boot. I like them so much am returning them and ordering a full size up and hoping for the beset. FYI have always worn Sam Edelman bootees in the past, similar style, with no problem.

Cute but uncomfortable with little padding or arch support. Feet and legs ached after an afternoon at a museum and shopping. I told my husband after this last attempt wearing them, "remind me not to wear these again." Replaced with the Blondo Villa which is more comfortable and slightly more flattering.

I bought these in black suede and they really did not last. I wore them occasionally and they look awful already, just a few months later. The black has faded and they look incredibly worn. They were cute. Fit also was a little off for my feet.

I have now owned these boots for 3-4 months. I have them in the black brahma, and putty. The fit is fine - it's leather, so it stretches and molds around your feet. The insole is hard, so these are not shoes you can comfortably walk/stand in for more than a couple hours. I tried wearing these out for a day of sightseeing and my feet KILLED me after about four hours. Most importantly, the heel caps fall off of both of my pairs constantly. Since it's plastic, I don't want to just use any glue to hold it together and I don't have a shoe repair service near me to fix it. So I've picked up a habit of stopping to check my heels to make sure the heel cap is still there.

Nice product, just not what I was looking for.

These shoes fit a bit weird and are smaller than expected. I can only wear the thinnest sock. I've had them a few months and the suede is already looking pretty worn down. Still wearing them, but not a huge fan.

I wear a 6.5 wide and find these to be a bit snug in the tie. Also, they are not a cold weather boot? Even indoors. My feet always freeze when I wear them even with decent socks. Very cute though!

Cute but the fit is off-they had to go back.

These were too big & the fit was poor. They went back & I kept the Ralph Lauren's instead which were great.

These were cute but the fit was off so they had to go back.

Very disappointed in the fit of these so they went back. They looked ok but fit poorly.

Even Wide Width was too narrow .... I was hoping wearing them around the house would stretch them out a bit, but no luck. They felt very narrow even in a 9W. So sad to send them back, because they were cute and well made.