Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

I ordered Wide and was shipped the 10M - not happy with that

I do in fact have big feet, but these seemed to emphasize it. They hit my ankle at a weird place too, and didn't work with the skinny jeans I wanted to wear them with. The slightly taller and slimmer at the ankle Roxy Eloise worked better for me.

I wanted these boots to fit so badly! They look almost identical to a pair of boots I've had for years and just LOVE but apparently a brand that doesn't exist anymore. I normally wear a size 7 or 7W (including for the boots I am trying to replace), but the 7W were huge - at least 1 to 1-1/2 inches too long in the toe and overall very loose. So I ordered 6W, and they also seemed too long, but were tight across the toes/ball of my foot and loose in the heel. I'm giving up on this boot, sadly, because they really are looks-wise, exactly what I'm looking for.

A nice fitting shoe but, while the color is attractive, I'm thinking I need something darker. Thank you, Zappos, for making shoe shopping so easy.

I've got high arches which means a high instep. I could barely zip these and they were snug over the top of my foot. Sad to return them as my Sam Edelman booties from two years ago are just about done because they were my favorites!

These boots are long on style, but did not fit right. I wear a medium width, but across the boot felt tight and the heel slipped, so there was no boot size to reorder. I felt overall that they could be more comfortable.

I agonized over these .. after all 2k+ buyers have loved them. But, firstly, they are very hard and stiff. Secondly the sizing is off. Thirdly they really make my feet look big. I ordered my usual (in everything including other SE boots) 9M and they were way too narrow. So I reordered a 9W that turned out to be both wider and longer, on a bigger last, including a fatter heel. I thought briefly of trying a 9.5 to see how they differ from the 9W but decided these are just not for me.

I really wanted to love this shoe. This Sam Edelman has the style I'm looking for but lacked the quality I'd like in a bootie to wear all day. The ball of my foot hurt right after wearing them around for a bit and it didn't cradle my foot well. If you have a regular width foot and don't require much in the way of support, this may be the option for you!

The pebbled leather looks nice and the heel height is just right for me, but ultimately I decided that I'd rather spend more money and get a higher quality shoe that I can wear for several years. As other reviewers have noted, the heel is plastic with a fake stacked leather veneer that will scrape off in time, leaving the tell-tale plastic behind. I also would rather have a leather sole so that it gives in time and is more flexible. I know that means I'll have to spend at least twice as much, but I'm not into "fast fashion." I'd rather spend the money upfront and have a shoe that will conform to my foot and that I will wear for years. I have several pair of Frye shoes and boots and while some didn't fit right and I returned them, most I've kept and have worn for years. I've only just recently replaced the heel on one of my Frye cowboy boots that I've had for ten years. I'm not saying I'll only buy that brand but I plan to buy something along those lines as an investment piece. You can always waterproof leather so I'm not worried about that. And when there's a serious downpour I'll wear rain boots.

Loved the idea of getting a black boot with some brown tons but the heel looked so so cheap. It looked like 100% plastic.

the nine and nine 1/2 were too large. I didn't feel comfortable ordering a 8 1/2, went with Blondo because they fit better size 9.

These are cute but I have to return them. Ordered my regular size in a wide and it was just too loose. Not much paddling in the insole. And they are very light grey, not really a tan which is what I was looking for. A cute shoe, just didn’t work for me.

I have somewhat narrow feet, and have never bought shoes that were too narrow for me until now. I got these boots in my regular size, 7.5, but they are too narrow to be comfortable with socks on. Even so, my heel slips if I try to wear them without socks. There is no padding in the bottom, so I would need even more room to put in a removable insole. They are an attractive color and versatile style.

Very cute bootie. However, they are very narrow and the right one seems a bit more snug and cuts my circulation off some. Didn’t realize it til I wore them on a trip/thru an airport. May return them as I have to leave the little zipper down on the right one(my feet are same size)

I loved the style but the inside felt like stiff cardboard! I can’t believe there was any padded material used. Very disappointing and I returned the,.

This was way too wide and was just clunky looking on. I have purchased the "Petty" in other colors and leathers, same size and they were fine. I was very dissappointed in this item!

Nice looking but couldn't get a good fit.

Very narrow and I don't have wide feet.

I can get my foot in and wear them for a short time, but they are not comfortable at all. They are very tight unless I wear super thin socks.

Absolutely love the pattern very sad it doesn’t fit across the top of my foot. It’s squeezing my knuckles to death especially on the inside by my big toes. Will be returning

Ordered Wide but yet felt like regular width, way too narrow on my foot & squeezed! Very uncomfortable.

Super cute just not comfortable to walk across the house let alone out.

I ordered my normal size 8 but they are very tight in the instep. The length was fine but even with thinner socks it was too tight.

not very wide but seemingly extra long

A little too narrow and not as supportive as I'd hoped. I hadn't tried this brand before so ordered this shoe in a couple sizes, but neither felt comfortable. I returned.