Customer Reviews Old Friend Ladies Scuff

I made the mistake of ordering both these and Uggs, similar style. Wrong move. I am a size 8 1/2 W and ordered size 8 in these. They were too short in length, and too wide in the box...a weird combination. My guess is that it's probably due to the poor sheepskin which is maybe 1/3 less than Uggs, and "messy." They looked nice, but had to go back. I could not walk without flopping around inside. (I kept the Uggs and ordered a 2nd pair of them.)

These slippers are heavy. They get bigger after you've worn them...much bigger. I should have ordered a size smaller. They are warm, but the sole is not flexible. I would not purchase again.

I chose these trying to save money. When they arrived and tried them on, I did not find them attractive or that they fit as well as UGGs. I decided that I have grown accustom to the wonderful world of UGGS. So I will splurge because, at the end of every day and the beginning of the day my feet will thank me.

It was cozy, but the sole is not as pictured, it's much less substantial. However, after a year, almost all of the lambswool has worn off the inside bottom of the slipper, leaving a slick mess. Since these are only worn an hour a day at most, and a few more on the weekend I would expect it to last longer. Very disappointing for the money. Everything else has held up well though.

This is a beautiful, well-made slipper; however, it is not true to size. It runs considerably smaller. It should not be tagged as 11-12 since it is closer to a 10.5 - 11. This was so disappointing.

I've had two pairs of these. The first pair, purchased 3 years ago, was incredible. The fleece was so thick I could barely get my feet in the slippers. Super warm and comfortable. Alas, the fleece compressed over 2 years and wore thin. So last year, I bought pair #2. Huge difference. The fleece was a much lower quality and roughly the same thickness as my already-compressed first pair. Still comfortable, but much lower quality and has already worn through in spots in 1 year what took multiple years with the first pair. Won't be buying another pair.

Length OK. I wear between an 8 and an 8 1/2; I ordered the 8-9 size. But way too wide. I'm keeping them but I do not like them. I am having trouble finding a slippers that fit.

These are comfortable, but way too wide, even in the medium width...and I don't have narrow feet, just average. I know from the past that these slippers don't last long, and I'm not happy with the slight rise in the heel, but, for the money, they're good for a couple of seasons. I do love the color.

This slipper is comfortable, but heavy, so they're loud on my wood floor. I thought they would have more cushion, but they are hard. Very similar to Uggs slippers, but heavier. I won't be buying them again.

Overall I think these shoes would have been comfortable but I am a true size 8 so I ordered the XL which is suppose to fit 8-9. They were about half a size too small (length) for my size 8 so if you are a size 9 these shoes would be be way too small.

I enjoy these slippers, but have to admit I think they were much too expensive. I wish I had waited to buy some similar slippers at Costco for a fraction of the price.

I tried these because my usual Uggs wear out too quickly. These are as comfortable and soft but don't stay on my feet as well. I find myself tripping over them.

I really love these slippers and have them in two colors, however, the quality is very uneven. I have had to return two pairs, including these navy blue ones, because one of the feet is misshaped! The right foot is wider and actually crooked! I sent another pair back because the shape of the shoe looking down was huge and bulging, unlike my first 'normal' pair. Very disappointing. I think I may have to try another brand. sorry. Also, I wish they could be a little narrower. I have a fairly wide foot and they get sloppy very quickly and fall off the foot too easily compared to other brands I have. Too bad because it's a nice shoe. Well made.

My mom sent me these slippers for Christmas and I so wanted them to work for me! They aren't pretty but they are soft and cozy and perfect for around the house. They run at least a size too small. I wear a woman's 11 or 12, depending on the shoe, and sadly even the XXL/woman's 11-12 did not work for me. If I could get these in the next size up I would hesitate.

These slippers would be more comfortable if they had been a bit longer. They seem about a half size smaller than I expected. Still I like them, they are very warm.

New design not so great - This is my favorite slipper. Well constructed, good quality, good value BUT there has been a design change that I don't like as well as the old design. The slipper now comes much higher up on your foot. Not as comfortable and looks more like a boxy, clunky boot than a slipper. There is a new sole that doesn't make any difference in the feel also. I kept my new ones but won't reorder.

Way Too Loose! I normally wear a 7 1/2 in shoes and a 7 in flip flops, so I thought the 6 1/2-7 1/2 size would be fine. My foot goes to the very, very end of the slipper, not even 1/4" to spare. But the top part of the slipper is so big and loose that my toes get tired just trying to hold the slipper on my foot! I even have a wide-ish foot. I would not recommend this slipper to anyone. The length was short and the width was gigantic.

I have a hard time keeping this slipper on my feet. Also the sole does not bend when you’re walking. It looks better than walking in it.

Warm slipper - This slipper is warm and somewhat comfortable. However, it provides little support and runs really wide.

Just OK - I was a little disappointed in this slipper. It has stretched out rather quickly. After a couple of times wearing this slipper they are now big on me.

Room for change - I love these slippers in so many ways, BUT they are dangerous. They are a scuff and you basically have to 'scuff to keep them on because they are scuff and the sole is heavy! It Sticks tho and you could kill yourself tripping. I finally put shipping tape on the toes. I would like to talk to the company about making some changes. For sure the sole so it is not dangerous, and going along with the other complaints it could have more cushion under the foot and better fleece under the foot. Mine are hardly used and all the fleece is worn off under the right heel. I really hope they will do this because they are the best in so many ways!!! Also, I agree that they are a little wide.

Softness of Scuff - We bought these slippers for my 12 year old daughter. I had recently bought a pair of shearling slippers from L. L. Bean. She and I both think that my slippers are much softer (and hers are much cuter) than mine.

Nice, but. . . . I purchased some slippers that look just like this from Eddie Bauer last year that were awesome. Based on the other reviews I thought I'd try these out. I work out of the home and the family isn't allowed to wear shoes in the house, needless to say - my slippers get a LOT of use. These felt great when I first got them. Warm - nice and snug, but within 2 weeks the interior fluff had matted down (I weigh 120) to the point that if I don't have socks on they just slip right off my feet. While there is an "outdoor" sole, there is no support for your foot like my last pair and feels no different than any other slipper. They still LOOK great - they just don't feel so.