Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

This is a beautiful shoe with superb styling and looks. My only issue is that it is much too narrow. I tried a half size larger to no avail. Major disappointment!

Very comfortable, pretty stylish too

My husband loves these shoes. He wants only a leather sole and these are one of the few brands that are affordable. Butit took about a half hour to lace one shoe. I see that the tongue is sewn down in place on one side which makes it awkwardly tight to maneuver the shoelace. I also think the holes were not punched properly on that side. Had to really work on it. Almost got in the car to bring to the brick and mortar store in Short Hills. Otherwise, handsome, comfortable, classic shoe.

These shoe are perfect. Exactly what I needed. Im on my feet all day and they are comfortable.

Great style with comfort

Beautiful pair of dressy shoes. Thank You

Shoes tight on the bridge (top) of the shoe. Had to remove the leather lining that was attached with foam for a better fit.

The first layer of the inner sole has detached from shoe in the first week. This is disappointing because I buy your shoes for the quality. I also pay a lot of money for these shoes and expect better. If you willing to resolve the issue I will rewrite my review.

The shoes look great but are not comfortable. The leather is stiff so less comfortable, the tongue is sewn to one side of the shoe which makes it difficult to tie, the soles have very little cushion and could use some form of a pad.

leather too stiff. could not fit my feet into the shoes

My fifth pair in all the colors. Melton wide fits me perfectly. Thanks for making wides

Very comfortable pair if shoes

The shoes are very good quality!

I love the style and fit of the shoe. I did not give it 5 stars because I wouldve liked a softer leather.

Overall these are really nice shoes. I had a similar pair of J&M shoes that lasted for over 20 years. I'm still breaking them in, but the fit is good. I wish there was a little more width in the toe area. Other than that, no complaints.

I love the style and fit of the shoe. I did not give it 5 stars because I would've liked a softer leather.

I looked forward to these shoes. However, I didnt expect them to be made from such a hard leather. Sure, the build quality appears good. But the leather quality isnt. Theyre no give, nothing soft; that just makes them uncomfortable.

This shoe fits well and looks great!

I ordered a pair of shoes 11 extra wide. When I tried them on I couldnt get my foot in the shoe. Its a beautiful pair of shoes with leather soles. If they had 11 4E I would buy two pair of shoes. One brown and the other black. Thx.

The shoe is beautiful but is very narrow.

The shoe is not the same quality and feel of Italian calfskin leather. It looked like. A patent leather shoe. Ive purchased your dress shoes for years and the workmanship and quality is just not the same.

I had the easiest and most pleasant experience ordering a shoe online. I ordered a pair of shoes online and immediately drove to the store for pickup. The store manager was there and they immediately filled the order even though it was past 5pm. I will definitely shop here for all my shoes and accessories.

I recently purchased a pair of black shoes from Johnston & Murphy, and I wanted to share my experience. I really like the sleek design and how versatile they are, easily pairing with both formal and casual outfits. The quality of the materials and craftsmanship is evident, making the shoes not only stylish but also comfortable for extended wear. What I absolutely love is the attention to detail in the stitching and the overall durability of the shoesthey feel like they'll last for years. If there's one area for improvement, it would be the break-in period. The shoes were a bit stiff initially, but they became more comfortable after a few wears. Overall, I'm very satisfied with my purchase and would definitely recommend Johnston & Murphy to others.

Perfect dress up shoes

A sharp design and style with a classic look that can be worn to an array of events or everyday at work. Leather looks and feels good, they broke in quickly. Wore to a wedding with a suit and then with shorts for dinner. Got many compliments.