Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

I loved these at first, very comfortable, and then after awhile they started squeaking on every step - pretty annoying and obvious. The local store had no fix and my local shoe repair shop applied some baby powder to reduce the noise - which only lasted a few weeks.

Love this shoe but need to return for 1/2 size larger than I usually wear. It appears to run a bit narrow.

I have a pair of these in tan. I usually get size 11 EEE or 11.5EEE. After tying those I went for size 10.5 EEE. They fit alright ( still not great) but slip a little in the back. I got the same size on black, and they fit completely different. They are to narrow in the toe, and too wide in the middle and back of the shoe. This leaves me with a shoe that pinches my toes, wrinkles, because it is too wide in the middle, and slips in the back. I tried a smaller size not width, and it still slipped. The problem is that it is too wide in the back and too narrow in the toe. I am at a loss as to what size to get.

It's not the style I want. The shoes are too hard and I feel uncomfortable in wearing this. It is too formal.

This is the first $100+ shoe Ive ever purchased. Bought from a store and was told I could have the shoe refurbished if need be. The leather bottom wore out. Understandably as I am in car sales. However when I went to get the shoe repaired in store, I was told this style is not recraftable. Very frustrating.

These shoes are almost unwearable because of the marks left on dark-colored carpeting. Something is coming off the bottom of the shoes. This happens with all three pairs I purchased. I will probably need to return them if the problem doesn't stop.

Shoes scuff and scar far too easily. Leather is poor quality.

Garbage. Bought them 8 months ago and already got holes in the soles, both of them.

Burgundy color doesn't hold up

I own several pairs of J&M shoes, however the recent models appear to be garbage. Two of mine separated at the sole, poor workmanship. I will move up to a $350-$500 pair of shoes but it will not be J&M.

I used the shoe for travel along with other J&M shoes. This is the newest shoe I have of the ten. Shoe #9 also wore out on the sole and came apart. J&M will not back their shoes. Do NOT buy if you wear dress shoes for travel. Their quality has been sacrificed in order to reduce production costs.