Customer Reviews Florsheim Berkley Penny Loafers

Shoes purchased for business/work. Shoes received were wrong size, clearly too tight. I have been a 10 1/2 for years and slightly narrow foot so get a C width when is available rather than a D. I have purchased other shoes recently at 10 1/2 and they fit fine, The left shoe here was so tight I almost could not even put it on. The right shoe also was tight but probably would have broken in ok eventually. But had to return the shoes because the left one was un manageable. Shoes made in India. I found out when I went to return ship the shoes that I had to pay UPS about $12 for the shipping. Very disappointing. I will not order shoes from Florsheim again.

Left Shoe damaged

1 shoe fit and the other was mismarked, way too small. couldn't even get it on my foot. never again will buy anything.

Great looking shoes but quality is highly suspect. The pair I received had part of the stitching falling apart. In addition, the leather was already cracking at the top. In short, I had to return them and am not getting a replacement pair. It was either poor quality of the product or poor quality control by the company in letting this pair of shoes get shipped.

I have been wearing Berkeley size 12 e for over 20 years. I recently three of them..non of them fit. too tight to get on!! so I ordered the 13...it is too loose. so I have switched to cole hawn size 12 and they slip right on. have you switched suppliers? I am really disappointed.

In order to have enough confidence in a product to order it "sight unseen" online, one must expect consistency. If one style of Florsheim 12-B's. fits my foot, ALL Florsheim 12-Bs should fit my foot. Those Berkleys were a full inch too short. On top of that, you actually expected me to PAY for the return of your mistake. In light of this, I will look for another brand that fits my foot, but is available in stores in my area.

Sole wore out Stitching on sole wore down Back of shoe leather tore

Delivery size 101/2 D was impossible to receive. I thought I would try 11 D. Did not fit. Attempted to return. was returned to me for lack of postage. I was the told you are sending me a return mailing label via computer still not received Also told first available shipment is may 1st but I can't place an order. Something is not working in your system Looking forward to your response. Sheldon David

Sizing issues

RETURNED BECAUSE SIZE IS TOO SMALL

Despite a price reduction, the shoe is not worth more than $30.00. The construction is shoddy. I expect the beef roll stitching to split. Very disappointed in the lowering of Florsheim standards.

The front upper wore out almost right away. I wore it normally in the summer as I have my penny loafers for years. I have a normal gait. Bought new in Summer, and within FIVE wear days (and I work in a carpeted office, but walk four blocks to work)the front upper wore out on the right shoe evidently because this shoe's front bulged out over the sole of the shoe in front and scraped the pavement with every step. I had to discard the shoe virtually brand new!This happened once before, years ago with a Dexter. I am giving Florsheim one more chance with this penny loafer purchase this time, since they had a good track record before this particular shoe was such a waste of money and disappointment.

These shoes make a loud noise when I walk, like many other Florsheim shoes I have purchased. I am going to return these shoes and never buy Florsheim shoes again.

The shoes are without a doubt mislabeled and too big. Now I have to pay to send them back and hopefully the right size shoes will be returned to me. Not pleased.