Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley - Oiled Leather

Would have been great without the elastic over the top of my arthritic foot. ?

This is a nice more stylish Birkenstock, but one of them is enough different in fit to be considered a second, so must return. :-(

I did like the way these looked and if they would have stayed on my foot when I walked, I am sure I would have loved them. I ordered size 6 but should have gotten 1/2 or 1 size smaller. The upper leather part did not come far enough up the top of my foot and that is why they were hard to keep on.

I love the color of these shoes, but the right foot was much looser than the left. I will return for a different style.

These shoes are too wide for my narrow feet especially in the heel. They will literally fall off my feet, so I had to return them. Too bad, they are really nice looking and if they did fit correctly, I think they would be very comfortable shoes. I purchased size 7- 7 1/2 narrow and I normally can wear 7 1/2 to 8 narrow.

The shoes were awesome. But the left shoe seemed more narrow than the right. The right was perfect. Left seemed defective

Precious shoe just not the Birkenstock fit and you expect. Shoe is somewhat smaller than a normal 38, more narrow and the arch was just not right. Cutest shoe in the new designs just not what was expected.

I own several pairs of Birkenstock Arizonas, in 36 and 37. The 37’s are usually a slight bit roomier than the 36’s, but the 36’s are the exact length of my foot, which means the arch and toe ridges are in just the right spot. I ordered these in 37, thinking I would have plenty of room. Maybe because they only offer the width in narrow, these didn’t fit. My toes scraped the front of the shoe when I lift my foot to step down. They also looked very small for my feet (again maybe it’s the narrow width). I’m not sure why they don’t offer these in the regular width, but definitely size up from your usual Birkenstock size. Caveat being if this is your first pair, then follow the US size guide (7 is my regular shoe size) which equates to what they say a 38 is (which I will try next).

Really liked the style, but it just lacked the comfortable "feel" of a Birkenstock shoe. After walking around the house in them for a bit, they just do not feel the way a Birkenstock shoe feels. There was an uncomfortable feeling from the underside of the buckle area and I was wearing socks. I'm sure if I had attempted to wear them with bare feet, they would have been irritated by the underside. If it wasn't for that, I probably would have kept the shoes.

The single biggest issue is that I go two different size shoes. The right shoe was the correct size and it was comfortable however I couldn’t figure out how the left shoe was so different until I looked at the sizes.

I have 4 pairs of Birkenstock sandals, all 39, but the 39 in this shoe is too small. Also, the arch support isn't as good as it is in the sandal. I am dissappointed.

This is truly a narrower shoe than your typical Birkenstock. I read reviews saying that the width wasn’t really narrow, so I took a chance - but while I could certainly get my wide foot in, they were uncomfortably tight across the toe box. If your feet are average, these are probably fine. But if you typically wear Birks to enjoy the spacious width, these are not going to be the same.

The leather was very stiff & overall appearance was more slipper like . As a shoe it was dowdy looking. Returned.

I have over pronation and this particular item makes it worse. I cannot straighten my ankles when I put them on. I haven't had this problem with other Birkenstock styles.

very light weight and feel like a cheep made shoe. Size and width are true, but no space for thicker socks

I really wanted to love these, I have Birkenstock Mayori sandals which are amazing. But these just don't fit correctly. I tried 2 different sizes, the arch support was minimal and I found my foot was actually pronating in them. Have to return them.

very comfortable, more like slippers, not enough suppport

I love this shoe….but I willam not able to order this style and other styles in regular. one reason I wear Birkenstock’s is I have a size d foot. if the company continues to not offer regular sizes I will not be able to order any more. I own 14 pairs.

The footbed didn't feel like my other Birkenstocks. I live in Birkenstocks because of the comfort but these just didn't have that comfort. I wanted to love them but was disappointed. The narrow width was not a problem just the comfort of the footbed.

I usually wear an 8.5 and the 39 fit perfectly. And I know other reviews warned that the shoes were narrow but I have a slightly wide foot and they fit fine BUT I got the bubblegum pink leather color (not the perforated style but solid matte light pink color) and the leather was weird and rubbery. I had to check again to make sure it wasn't the "birki-flor" plastic material. The stitching was kind of wonky and the leather looked ugly so I am returning. Maybe the suede styles are a better bet.

DIsappointed. They are pretty cute, but not quality I’d expect. The sole is still the good Birkenstock design, but the materials all feel cheap. The leather is thin, stiff, and uncomfortable. One shoe has a painful seam where elastic attaches under the buckle. I had a pair of the suede/ shearling version which was much more comfortable—but the shearling soon wore through completely. Thought I’d give it another try for summer but these are very disappointing.

I love birenstocks but these didn't have the usual arch support of other styles. Disappointed with the fit and am returning.

I bought these in a 41 based on the recommendations- I normally wear a 10 1/2 N, except in athletic shoes- then I wear an 11N. The shoes were too wide for me, even with the buckles adjusted down to the last notch. At that point i tried them on with socks, thinking they might work. They still did not feel secure on my feet and the socks made them too short. I have worn birkenstocks in the past which were able to fit my narrow feet, but these had to go back.

I love the look of these so much. Too bad they were so narrow, couldn’t even put them on.

These were huge on my feet, width-wise. I wouldn't be able to keep them on my feet. I was very disappointed as I thought this would be a good comfortable yet stylish shoe to wear with jeans.