Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley - Oiled Leather

These feel like they were tailored to my specific feet. The 39s fit (my usual Euro size; my US size is 8 or 8.5. My feet are definitely not narrow and the width is fine. (I do wish they would rename their widths as it can be misleading). I’m not 100 percent convinced these are the right style for me in terms of looks. They remind me of men’s loafers from the 70s...I love pink but I’m on the fence here.

I've been spoiled by the Birk's with a soft footbed and can't go back. That's not to say that these aren't comfortable, but my old feet appreciate more cushioning. Also, I like this style, but didn't look good on my long, narrow feet.

Weird little shoes that I love so much! I got the silver-sparkly white ones in my usual size of 37, which fit my size 7.5 moderately wide feet quite well with a little break in. The all suede lining is heavenly (keeps feet dry). The shoe is a little hard (not cushioned). For now, I mostly wear these around the house.

I don’t have a wide foot. I’d say it’s “normal” width. I was concerned this would feel tight being that it only comes in narrow. However, it fit perfectly. I bought a 38 and love it and is comfortable.

I love the fit, feel and look of this shoe. I haven’t been able to wear them out yet, but around the house, everything feels and looks great. I gave one less star overall because the leather on the outside right shoe, collapses in and makes the shoe shape imperfect. I’ve massaged it out hoping it will right itself, but the shape continues to stay collapsed in. Otherwise, love the shoe.

I really liked this Birkenstock Buckley shoe. It was a perfect fit for my thin foot. However, I am returning because just below the buckle area inside the shoe it constantly rubbed a small bone on the top of my foot and I could not adjust it out. Also, you will need to wear socks with this shoe as the inside upper is rough to the top of your foot. And I had to add a thin pad because it is hard to the bottom of the foot. Style wise and fit wise, very nice. Thanks again, Zappos, for your liberal return policy!

I have a pretty wide foot, so the narrow width just didn't cut it

I bought these thinking that with my normal B width shoe size that they would fit comfortably. However, I usually wear the medium/wide width in the Birkenstock Arizona. Although I got my foot in these I tried them on with a heavier Birkenstock sock and they were uncomfortable and too tight. I do wish they came in the regular width.

Nice style and quality. Fit was a disappointment, although you see the arch they felt like a flat shoe with no support.

Sadly returning these shoes. Love the style but they are narrower than all of my other Birks. I wear a 38, which is what i ordered, but if you have a high instep like I do, these probably won't work. Highly disappointed.

The left one was wider than the right, really disappointed because I loved the look. Not really adjustable.

Love the look of the shoe but they were not comfortable. Also the soles were very slippery

Narrow IS NOT narrow. I have tried loads of brands, looking for a narrow shoe. Even though Birkenstock labels these "narrow" they are as wide or wider than every Regular I own. Actually dangerous to wear. It's a shame because the footbed is very comfortable.

Comfy however super bulky and ran big. Went to a store to try on because I really liked but couldn’t get the sizing right. I am NEVER a narrow but tried on my normal size (41) in a narrow and that worked great.

Cute. But. They cause my feet to pronate noticeably. Wish I could wear them. Unfortunately they won’t work for me. 5 stars for cute.

This is a really cute shoe but the narrow fit me like a wide width. I am going to return them.

These shoes are so cute and I was excited about them because it said narrow. They were not narrow and felt more like wide that even a medium. I was so sorry that I had to return them.

I really wanted these shoes to work. Very cute shoes. Does not have the usual Birkenstock insert. I have high arches. This style would not support my arches. Unfortunately I had to return.

I am a Birkenstock fan and ordered the same size I wear in their Arizona sandal. This style was significantly larger and wider. I had to return for a smaller size. Not sure if smaller size will work yet!

I was really hoping this would be my shoe and was already planning to buy 2 more in different colors for spring. Unfortunately this style doesn't have enough support for my high arches. I am packaging now to return.

I really wish this could have been my new favorite shoe. Believe me I tried to make it work.?I have a high arch. The arch support is better than no arch but not by much. I tried putting my Orthoheel in the shoes but it just wasn’t going to work. Tomorrow I will be returning the shoes. I think this shoe would work well for someone with flat to moderate arches.

I love the look of these shoes, but they didn’t work for me. I was hoping that, even though they are the narrow width, I’d be able to wear them, but the forefoot was too narrow and the seam rubbed my bunion. I sure wish they would make these in the regular width!

I ended up returning the shoes..love the style & color however the right shoe was more narrow than the left..not by my foot but by actually measuring the difference, also the tread on the right foot came out more. I felt like the shoes were "seconds" or Birkenstock quality has hit rock bottom. Quality was inferior.

I was sent the wrong style with the shearling liner. Returned as I did not want the shearling liner version. True to birkenstock great support.