Customer Reviews Birkenstock Buckley - Oiled Leather

This shoe was too big for me, though it was my normal Birkenstock size. Also, it's suede and the edges on the sides are unbound so you know it's going to stretch like crazy. Was hoping for a perfect southern CA winter shoe but this is not it.

This unlined style is definitely not for the slim foot! I already have the Buckley in narrow with the shearling lining and they are terrific so I was disappointed the unlined version could not be adjusted small enough to work. Sadly, already returned.

Did not love these. Same size as my Arizona and way too big.

Cute shoes, but they didn't have enough arch support or cushion for my feet. I gotten pretty used to the soft footbed Birkenstocks and this shoe is just too firm and flat.

This is a third style of Birkenstock shoes I've purchased that I didn't like. The width of a 38 is same as my other two pairs, but felt wider. After trying them on I didn't like the design. Again, this design may not look well on narrow feet. I chose silver color and the shoes stood out like sun shining. Sorry, I'll stick to other designs.

Not loving these like I usually do. This may be the first Birkenstocks I've returned because of not getting that good feel of comfort as soon as I walk in them. They almost feel too lightweight to me. I like that the style is improved from the bulky looking clogs, but it's not working for me.

This shoe wasn't as cute in person as I had hoped it would be. The color was more tan than I was expecting. It looked darker online. I typically have to wear the soft footbed Birk's but had hoped to make the original footbed work with these. It just wasn't meant to be for me. I need the softer comfort of the soft footbed. Thanks to Zappos for their gracious return policy.

This show has a very uncomfortable elastic under the front piece.

The sole of the show did not in any way align with my feet. SO UNCOMFORTABLE! these went back.

My toes did not align with the toe box of the shoe. Also the arch support was off.

really uncomfortable

I know it was marked as a narrow size, but it was even narrower than other narrow birks I've had. It also had a weirdly high arch, not like any birks I've worn (and I've gone through dozens of pairs in the last 40 years). Total fail.

These shoes have a seam where the elastic is sewn in under the tongue that left two bloody gouges on the top of each foot. My feet were messed up for weeks. Not Birkenstock comfort. I loved the look, but it isn't worth the pain.

VERY disappointing. Though promoted as a narrow (which usually fits me in their sandals) these are way too wide for my AA width feet. The arch support also seems significantly less than In sandals and even some other shoes I have bought, and the toe grip area isn't much. To top it off the insole isn't removable, so no way to enhance the fit with an something below the included insole.

Ordered Tea Suede 2 twice, received wrong color twice. Received Tea, Not Tea 2.

Not as comfortable as my other Birks. The "flap" at the top made it uneasy to just slid my foot in and out also.

Very disappointing. They are like all Birks. well made and comfortable if they fit. They were sized extremely small. I think if you have a narrow foot and toes that are not squared off they may work but size up.

This was disappointing. Usually I love Berkinstock these were way too narrow and a full size smaller than the other styles. I'll be going back to the old styles.

These were much bigger than my other narrow 39. I think one of the two shoes might be a regular. They run at least 1/2 size larger. I'm hoping the size smaller will be a better match up.

Didn't fir. Much too large.

I’ve had 3-4 prs of Birks but these are the most uncomfortable shoes. I thought I had to break them in little but the soles have a weird footbed and the elastic strap is way too tight (and I don’t have fat feet). I do not recommend

These shoes look great on the feet. Very stylish but I was very disappointed with how uncomfortable they are. The material rubs the top of the foot which hurt on the first step. Also, the way the elastic is set on the top makes the shoe very awkward to walk in.

Really like this shoe, but the right shoe fit perfectly and was very comfortable while the left shoe did not fit. The elastic across the top was too tight and left a raw spot on top of arch. Someone else wrote about this in their review and can't help but think I received their return, especially since the shoe did not arrive in a Birkenstock shoe box, but in a plastic bag without the usual paper stuffing. Quite disappointing. Will be returning the Buckley gray taupe.

The shoe looks so cute and is marked “narrow”. Not narrow enough, even with wool socks. I returned these and will try a different style. I love the Mayari sandal in 40N and had hoped these would fit as well. I’ve ordered the Oswego and hope for better luck.