Customer Reviews Birkenstock Madrid Big Buckle - Leather

Returned them. These were the most uncomfortable sandals I ever wore. i read that they needed to be broken in, but for the price, I couldn't risk it. Love the look, though

I wanted to love these so much! They are super cute but not made for anything but really narrow feet unfortunately

not super comfortable

Buckle rubbed the top of my foot. It was hard to keep the shoes on when walking. They look lovely, but are uncomfortable. Will go back to an older style.

This sandal looks nice but doesn't feel nice on. It's hard to walk in and keep on while walking. The most questioning part about this order was the generic box the shoes were shipped vs. the traditional Birkenstock packaging with paperwork.

This sandal looks nice but doesn't feel nice on. It's hard to walk in and keep on while walking. The most questioning part about this order was the generic box in the shoes were shipped vs. the traditional Birkenstock packaging with paperwork.

These look good but I found them to be too heavy and stiff for me. I didn't like them overall

I own this shoe with the suede footbed and it is perfect in every way. I decided to order the black, but wanted the buckle to be silver, so had to go with the smooth leather lining. NO COMPARISON! The smooth lining version not only doesn’t feel the same, it doesn’t fit the same. It seems smaller, no matter how I adjust the strap. That smooth leather footbed has nowhere near the comfort and the secure feeling of the suede. I only tried them out in my house, so they are on the way back. Guess I will have to sport that gaudy gold buckle if I want the black, but probably not. Unfortunately, that is a game changer for me.

Comfortable but only good for walking very short distances. The buckles caused large bruises on the top of my feet.

The top of my foot is very high and these dug into the top of my foot when walking. Wouldn’t have been able to walk 10 feet. I’ll need to return. The style is very cute and I wish it would have worked with my foot.

There was a gap even when on the last buckle hole—and this was my usual 39 narrow. The material was stiff—it pays to get real leather instead of patent leather so these are going back.

Received broken, scuffed sandals. So disappointed. I was really looking forward to wearing these this weekend. Instead they are being sent back. Very cute though.

Was still too loose with ordering a size down, sadly returned.

For me these did not seem secure on my foot when I walked. I prefer the multi-strap / multi-adjustment styles. Liked the look - just not the feel

Not my first pair of BIrks, I always wear the same size and they have a little wiggle room. Not these, they are narrow through the toe box and short in length as well. My toes were practically hanging off the front of the shoe. Super disappointed since I really loved the style and knew I would get a lot of wear had they fit properly. OOwell.

The fit was a little big in width. Style looks great and the leather material smooth.

Very nice but not holding well

I love this shoe but didn’t realize that the footbed was leather. The color transferred to my feet (black) and the shoes are not very comfortable. I am wearing them around the house to see if they will become more comfortable. Slipped on my other Madrid’s and could feel the difference. Love the style and will try and keep them.

Just wasn’t comfortable and tricky to walk around in.

Very narrow even after adjusting the buckle.

I can't keep these on in either size! Will have to return both 40 and 41! I love 2 strap Birks!

These fit just like all my other Birkenstock purchases over the years. But I did return due to soles being smooth leather? My feet seemed to slip when I walked in them. I much prefer the suede/leather soles.

I really liked these in the picture of these sandals but in real life they are kinda cheap looking. Not like my other birks. I’ll still keep them as they are stylish and more comfy than other stylish/ trendy sandals but definitely not what I expected or expect from Birkenstock

Cute but not as comfortable as my other birkies.

I always wear a size 38 in Birkenstock, but this style in particular felt small. Ordered a 39 and they fit perfectly!