Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari Oiled Leather

The shoe fits great, but it is not the same color as pictured

Did not even try them on, look as if they were worn. This is the second time I have ordered Birkenstocks from Zappos. Like the previous pair, they looked worn and used. I kept the first pair I purchased about a year ago and though I would give Zappos another try. Never again.

Won’t be buying Birkenstocks from Zappos again. Not sure if they buy directly from the company? My the straps on one of my sandals completely fell off after very light usage. They won’t accept a return. Buy from Nordstrom instead.

Did not fit....too big.. I ordered the next size down....love Birkenstocks!

I like the way they look but I would not recommend this purchase. The blue leather is leaking on my skin makin my skin stain.

Hurt between my toes and upper part of foot. Had to return.

I have moderately narrow feet. These felt like boats. Very wide!

I love the look and feel of these shoes. This is the 2nd pair for me. The first pair lasted a few years. This pair broke at the toe strap after only wearing a few months. disappointed!

Hi, I'm Jenn and I'm a Birkenholic. Seriously, other than athletic shoes when needed, they're all I wear. I have been wearing Birks for 43 years. I've always been the same size. So, obviously, it's not like I'm new to the brand. These are waaay narrower than the other 5 pairs of Mayoris I've had. What gives, Birkenstock? Sad to have to return these, my old ones are shelled. Dangit!

I got blisters from them

Beware! The photo of this shoe looks to be a strong yellow color. It is not even close! It is actually an apricot color which is what it is named, but I went by the photo.

The arches were uncomfortably high in the beginning, but got more comfortable with time. These shoes looked very stylish . The straps got a bit loose with time and after a year both shoes were cracked through. They don't handle daily ware very well. I would not suggest this as your go to shoes if you want them to last a year. I really wanted to love these.

This shoe is very uncomfortable and bothered my arches. Had to return.

Cute but the straps were hard and rubbed my big toe. I have other birkies and they’re not like these. I was extremely disappointed.

LOVE these shoes - enough to buy them twice BUT each pair has broken (strap snapped near the big toe), rendering them un-wearable (one after two seasons, another after only one!) Such a bummer, especially considering the expense and Birkenstock's reputation.

The color is faded looking. Looks like it has been worn for years.

I loved these sandals, but the toe loop just frayed and broke at the base as other customers have complained. I don’t think it can even be repaired. I’m disappointed because otherwise these were great sandals and I paid more than I normally would for sandals because of Birkenstock’s reputation for quality.

This review is for a Berki-Flor version. The Birki-Flor product was inferior to the leather all around. I am returning it. It is a completely different product and there is really no comparison. The style was cruder, the arch support was not there, and it was clumsier to walk in than the leather. At one time, they offered a non-leather product that was similar in quality to the leather, but it is no longer available. I hope that they continue to offer the superior leather shoe because it is/was a great product!

Not a soft shoe bed as described, very hard inner sole. Have suffered from heel pain for over 10 years, this sandal is not good for that, Crocs are better as they offer more cushion for the heel.

I just had my second pair break at the toe strap after 16months. They are super comfortable. This style just isn’t durable.

I can't believe it, I have had these for 3 months and they broke! I have been wearing Birkenstocks for years and currently have other styles that have been going strong. Spending over $100 for sandals means they last longer than one season of once a week wear. Returning!

I love Birkenstocks and in particular the Mayari style, in fact, currently, I have three pairs in various colors. The blue pair was as comfortable as the other pairs until, i got wet walking on a sidewalk through sprinklers. The color bled on my feet and I had to scrub quite harshly to remove it (see pic). Not sure they are safe to wear. I would definitely NOT recommend this color and I’m having second thoughts on a brand that I was previously trusting.

Comfort is great, and this is my favorite sandal, but QUALITY IS TERRIBLE. The Birko-flor material is not durable. I have had three pairs of the Mayari and the toe ripped in the same place on all three pairs, each with one season of moderate wear. Sadly Birkenstock will not make any Narrow width Mayari in leather. Trying Mephisto instead, the quality seems better.

I own 6 pair of Berkenstocks. Love them! I usually wear size 6 regular shoe which corresponds to 37. But this style with the toe strap, I need Size 36 even tho it corresponds to size 5, 5-1/2. This was my 4th pair of this style so I knew what I needed. For a 2 or 3 strap, I need a size 37. Zappos is great about returning, so don't be unhappy. They will make it right. The materials are great and last years. Get several pair. They've been voted #1 sandal!