Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy XC4 TR1 Sport Hybrid

I returned to exchange from a M to a W. Because the tongue was fixed in rather than loose it really pinched my instep. Other than that I liked the style and comfort. I'll be anxious to see if the W size makes a difference.

Great sport shoe! The fit, comfort, and style are great!! Inner liner and soles are very comfortable. From the first time I wore them they felt like they were broke in already.

The shoe weighs heavy. For sports or training this will be negative.

Shoes are well made but even in dual width when you remove innersole is too narrow. 4 shoes arrived, one had prepaid label three I had to do online. Over 10 business days and still missing return credits.

Bought these and realized after getting them that I had to remove the insole for wide option. Not as comfortable as with the insole in, and as they looked similar to another pair I had, I sent them back.

The shoe is light and fits true to size. But the top of my foot feels tight and hurts.

Looks are better than comfort. Also, leashes always come undone

Feels very cushiony and instep has great support but it feels a bit too snug for me.

JM are my brand, but this shoe is over-articulated and the woven portion was uneven. Make me an XC4 waterproof shoe that is strong, simple, and sensible enough to go from boat to boardwalk.

Shoe is great, unless you really need a wide. Moving up a half size didn't fix it, just made it too long. Returns take a long time.

I am not a fan of the m/w combo - I like the style, color comfort. Slips in heel

Only available as M/W, didn't fit.

There is no separate tongue. hard to get a firm fit so my heel slips.

Hard to put on but comfortable

The look and feel nice, but they are big and clunky.

Looked nice but was a poor fit so I returned them.

Returned. I have foot issues and the instep was too tight. I switched them out for the Mile U-Throat and they are very comfortable, great rocker sole.

Shoes are good quality but definitely not a Wide when removing the insole. Too tight to wear and have to return.

These actually seem like a great shoe. I usually were a 9.5 and have a wide foot. Only problem is they were WAY too tight on the top of my foot. The way the shoe is made like a sock, there is no tongue. So no way to adjust that so they have to go back. So bummed.

I wear 10.5 shoe and have other pairs of JM but this pair are a very narrow tight fit

I bought these to use as a travel sneaker and thought that it would be helpful that they are also waterproof. I just didn't like the overall feel of them as they were a little clunky. I have other JM sneakers like the RT1-Luxe that fit great and these just were not for me.

Quality seems legit but their sizes are way larger than every other brand I've purchased shoes from and they don't make below an 8. Their 8 fits like a 10. I'd give them a try if you're a 10 and above otherwise I'd pass.

Shoes look great. Decent build. They are comfortable but the insert (in a different spot on each shoe) had a crease in them making them super uncomfortable with the inserts inside the shoe. I had to remove them and wear them "wide".

Nice look but the mesh upper was very wrinkled when I cinched up the laces.

I bought two pairs. One blue and one grey. The blue feel great in size 13. The grey ones are really tight in 13.