Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy XC4 TR1 Sport Hybrid

It may be because the shoe runs small but I was expecting a more comfortable fit. The shoe is well made for this price point.

Very nice, comfortable shoes. They ran a a bit large so I had to return them for a smaller size

Very lightweight shoe, good materials. The insole is taking some getting use to. I have a surgically repaired right foot and with the insole in, it's a little snug. With it out, it's a little too roomy. I have XC4 golf shoes that fit perfectly. Great looking shoe

I love these shoes, but on the bottom of the shoe there is a kind of trench that collects mud or other debris. The shoe is waterproof, which I need, but waterproof with an underside that collects debris and cannot be worn past the door one comes in. As I said, I love the shoe, but this design flaw is real. One must look at the bottom of the shoe to see the plastic. built in trench. For that reason, I don't think I'd recommend the product.

I was surprised that the shoe has no tongue. Therefore, loosening them is not an option. The fit is a little snug but not unbearable.

Pleased that you can remove inserts and the shoes become a wide width. Very comfortable and stylish

This is a comfy shoe and has a nice ride. I have no complaints and the coolest thing is taking the insole out to make a wide fit or leaving it in for medium. The only reason I give it a 4 is because it works as a dress shoe but it looks like a running shoe on foot. I didn't realize the sole was so thick. Still overall great shoe and will be a nice change of pace!

Good looking shoe. Fits well. Light I didn't realize no tongue in the shoe. That is new to me but so far I like it.

I like the shoes but they are hard to put on. I normally wear a size 9 but ordered a 9 1/2- still hard to put on. Separated tongue should make a big difference.

As it's a waterproof shoe it ran small, so I sent it back and asked for a larger size. We'll see once I get the new one.

I really like the look of these, they are casual but semi dressy, making them flexible enough to wear in various occasions. They are supposed to have heat/cool control or something but the waterproof feature makes them still seem hot to me. I somewhat expected that though. I would give them 5 stars if they actually felt more breathable like the description suggested.

These are a Christmas gift for my husband. He already has two pairs of these shoes and just loves them. However, I'm not sure about the durability of these shoes. I don't believe he has had them all that long and one of the shoes has developed a crack across the sole and it makes a horrible snapping noise when walking. With what this pair of shoes cost originally, I would have expected more in the durability category.

The fit was OK. The back heel seemed too high for me. Made it uncomfortable. So I returned them.

Nice style

Very comfortable shoes! Highly recommend.

Seems to be made of a quality material however, the brown color distracts from the overall look. The gold color use as part of the sole would have more complementary to the color combination (too many different colors) For wide foot size, you must remove the top inner sole cushion in order to achieve a comfortable fit however, this takes away from the overall feel of comfort when the sole is removed.

Super comfortable! They look wider in real life than they do in the photos, but still look pretty good!

Nice, comfortable shoe for Walking. well made. Could use a little but more lift in heal cushion. Not likely a perfect match for intense athletics endeavors. recommend at sale price but not at full retail.

The only reason I did not give a 5 rating is my narrow heel did not produce a snug fit.

I had previously purchased the light gray color of this and I was so impressed of the comfort that I bought the black color also; but unfortunately the right shoe of this new pair is not as comfortable as the left, as if it's coming out of my foot while walking, and if I remove the padding, it is too large inside. Well I guess I have to get used to it cause I really like the style.

Great show but I have to take the insert out to get the wide fit. Hoping for the wide fit without having to take the insert out.

Comfortable and light.

Awesome shoe and super comfy and great fit

Great look. A little snug and not really a slip-on. Still, worth the effort

Overall good but too tight making my feet hurt on the top after wearing it for 3/4 hours.