Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe

Love the shoes, but disappointed that they are not available in wider sizes!

My shoe size is 11. The shoes I bought ran big for a size 11. I didn't return them because of the hassle.

I love the suede shoes. The most comfortable shoes I own. Unfortunately, the front of the shoe is peeling off of the soles already.

Nicely looking shoes. Relatively comfortable and lightweight. However, only two days of wearing on a trip to Denver caused them to be scuffed all over and the leather looks like have worn them for years.

The JM shoe I actually wanted - the Howell Plain toe - was discontinued and this was the most similar item in the new JM catalog. The Upton is less comfortable and less classy while somehow also more formal. I would return it if I could. I'll be looking for another brand.

We ordered 2 different colors and kept the darker which suits my husband's wardrobe better!

These are nice looking shoes, but the first few times I wore them, my feet were sore.

I have been wearing Johnson and Murphy shoes for the last decade and I have not had an issue with the fit, but this shoe must run smaller than any of the other shoes I have purchased. The shoe felt comfortable at first, but as I walked around in the them, they started crunching my toes to the point where I couldn't wait to take them off. I was going to eventually buy a larger size to give it another try.

It's a nice shoe, but the sizing was way off. Retuned immediately for a larger size.

You'd quality control needs to do a better job.One pair I ordered was fine ,second pair was damaged .Sent one pair back for a replacement and have not received replacement yet.

I returned these. They're good looking, and mostly comfortable but no padding around the ankles like most other JM shoes I own. Couldn't do it! I exchanged for XC-40 and they are amazing!

The shoe caused a blister on both heels the first time I wore them. Really ticks me off.

Nice looking shoe, unfortunately no arch support. Completely flat inside and very uncomfortable. Returned.

Very comfortable and stylish. However the heel and the border it begins to peel. The rubber is very soft, and it wears quickly

They scuff to easily. This is my 3rd pair. Didn't seem to have the same quality.

Good looking shoe. I have been wearing JM shoes for years and always ordered a size 9 that fit great. Ordered a size 9 in this shoe and fit is a bit tight. Hoped shoes would break in to usual fit. However, so far no luck, fit is still tight.

These shoes looks pretty good but they will give you blisters around the back of the heel. Very cheap material there that rubs through your socks. Wouldnt recommend.

My husband said they scuff easily but they are comfortable.

I'm a J M regular with 100% satisfaction with every purchase, not sure I can say that about the Uptons I just got. The initial fit and feel was great but after 3 times wearing them the left shoe has gotten uncomfortable and ill-fitting. Also the finish has changed, not sure how they'll look after cleaning. I love the brand but would've picked another style in retrospect.

Would prefer more sole support

Unfortunately these did not work for me. JM is a great brand as I own 2 other pair. These seem to run large and the smallest size available is an 8. They were exactly what I was looking for so very disappointed.

I love the way they fit. They sold me a cleaner that has seemed to stain them. So they don't look as nice.