Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Upton Plain Toe

Its a nice shoe, but the sizing was way off. Retuned immediately for a larger size.

Youd quality control needs to do a better job.One pair I ordered was fine ,second pair was damaged .Sent one pair back for a replacement and have not received replacement yet.

The shoes I ordered arrived quickly, which is usually the case with Johnston & Murphy. They are comfortable and light weight, as advertised. The style looks good with different types of pants. To protect the leather, I treated them with KIWI Shoe Waterproofer in the spray can. One drawback is the leather does scuff easily. I will need to be careful not to wrap my feet around the bottom of my office chair. I am not sure if there is an easy way to remove the scuff marks on this particular type of leather.

The shoes I ordered arrived quickly, which is usually the case with Johnston Murphy. They are comfortable and light weight, as advertised. The style looks good with different types of pants. To protect the leather, I treated them with KIWI Shoe Waterproofer in the spray can. One drawback is the leather does scuff easily. I will need to be careful not to wrap my feet around the bottom of my office chair. I am not sure if there is an easy way to remove the scuff marks on this particular type of leather.

Love my new shoes. Tired of buying cheaper shoes that dont fit correctly. Will be buying from here again!

The shoe is comfortable to walk in but when I drove in them they dug into the back of my foot.

Originally they felt very good and comfortable, after wearing a couple of time they became very uncomfortable. I thought they would be just like the Amhurst (BLK Knit) I purchased. I have worn the shoes a couple of times and they are not getting any more comfortable. I have worn them out side a couple of times, but I would like to return them if possible. The shoe itself is great looking, but not. for me to wear.

I have been through two pairs of these, both pair had the sole separating from the shoes. I wore them for a few weeks before noticing, so figured it was too late to return them. I took them to a local shoe shop to see if they could get it fixed. They have glued both the heel and toe twice, and they still come apart. Very disappointed for a shoe this expensive. The fit and comfort are great, and love the look...just very disappointed in the quality and issues with the sole.

Really nice look and feels good on my feet.

Couldnt be better!!!

Comfortable & stylish

I give these a 5 star rating. Very comfortable, soft leather, and the cushioning is soft but very supportive, feels like walking on pillows. These shoes are very lightweight and styled for work or pleasure!!! I received several compliments the first couple of days I wore them!!!

Extremely comfortable for or a physician who stands all day long in office and hospital. My wide feet felt "at home" in the medium shoes I settled for as a wide version was not available. The quality is what you would expect. I ordered myself 2 more of this model. The grey color looks great and stylish, but he shoes looked even better when worn.

Nice, comfortable shoe. Goes well with jeans or dress pants. Only complaint is that the leather seems to scuff/mark up easily.

The heel near the ankle is a little tough on my foot

Nice shoes overall and a great option for the workplace. The ordering process was cumbersome and slow and I am not sure I will order directly from Johnston & Murphy in the future.

Good fit. Comfortable. Color more pleasing than expected.

Was shocked at how comfortable these are. They are like slippers on my feet. And they look good too. Only downside so far is they seem to scuff more easily than most shoes. But so far I love them.

Comfortable shoe

As with most J&M shoes, they are so light and comfortable, while still being stylish & professional. Feel like slippers on my feet!

Very comfortable shoe and love the look. I love how its black or brown on bottom instead of white, I hate that style

I've purchased Johnston & Murphy shoes many times over the years and have been completely happy with them. This shoe is the exception to my J&M experience. The first pair I received had a defective welt on the inner right heel area so I returned them for another pair. The second pair arrived with the same defect in the same area. I can only assume that this is due to some tooling problem so I gave up and returned the second pair also. Other than that, they are beautiful shoes I had planned to wear to my daughter's wedding but was not meant to be.

They scuff to easily. This is my 3rd pair. Didnt seem to have the same quality.

Great looking shoe. Comfortable right out of the box.