Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Shootie

I could not even get this bootie on my foot. I am always a true 7.5 and ordered that size. I think you would have to go up a full size. I can’t tell you how they felt. But, I love the Frye brand for its aesthetics. I was prepared to pay double for the look and feel of Frye, but am returning. I bought the Clarke’s which are half the price, have a dual zipper, and feel really nice. They look almost like the Frye, but of course, not quite. But given the price and fit, I’ll be very happy with the Clarke’s.

It was difficult getting my foot inside the shoe because the bottoms are so smooth my foot kept sliding. I love Frye boots for 40 years, but these I had to return .

I absolutely LOVE these boots. the are comfortable right out of the box for full day of wear. the leather is soft and supple. they run large, so I ordered a half size down. I have a narrow foot, so this might not work for a wide foot. I have plantar fasciitis and there is room for my orthodox. the heel is low and comfortable. this is my second pair of frye boots, and I am totally satisfied. they're a bit pricey, but worth it.

Usually take size 8 in Frye but in this shoe 8 was too big. The 7.5 fits perfectly. Nice looking shoe, but they dig into ankle at zipper. Will keep and hopefully will break in over time.

I have narrow bony feet, wear Frye for years, and the toe-box on these are horribly tight - to the point to say it was painful for more than a few minutes on baby toes.

I LOVE Frye boots, and I loved this bootie / shootie. But I could not get my left foot into it (had a major foot break years ago and two surgeries). I am so sad to have to return these, because they are so cute!

Comfortable but too long

Beautiful boot, but sizing is runs big (for me). I wear a 6 in everything...except Frye. My tall boots are all 5.5 and fit me great. For these, I let myself be thrown off by other people's and ordered a 6, but they are too big for me. Too bad about the back-and-forth, because it turns out 5.5 is my size in these ones, too.

My favorite work bootie. Fits slim under pants, looks smart, has held up with a little leather care and so comfortable once you wear them in!

This is a classic, well-made bootie, and I was so excited to find it on sale. However, there is no grip support on the bottom of the boot, and it was VERY slippery, even walking on carpet in my home to try them on. I'm returning it.

The style is sleek and clean in style. The leather has a beautiful, smooth finish. I want to keep the shoe, however, it runs narrow.

This is a GORGEOUS shootie, and I wish I could have worn them! I have an unusual higher arch due to surgeries for broken mid-foot and I could not fit my left foot into the shaft. The Carson Piping Booties have been my go-to for years since the injury, but sadly, the Melissa is a no-go for me.

I did have to return these because the toe box cramped my toes from the top.

The style of the booties did look exactly the same as the picture.I did not like the front of the booties,for me they had a masculine look,which overall was disappointing.It was also a tad bit hard to get my feet in.

Disappointed.