Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey Slip-On

Needed a new pair of casual shoes for a casual dress work environment. Thought these looked great and versatile. Took some time to break them in and they rubbed the back of my heels raw in the process. After a few weeks of wear, I noticed the left shoe started to make an audible squeaking noise. I returned them for a replacement pair, and after just a couple of weeks they are having the same issue.

I am still waiting to receive this shoe in a wide size to compare the fit. It has been more than two months -- not impressive service.

Poorly built shoe

Nice, but not great.

This was a replacement for a well-worn pair of the same shoe. Third pair. Changes since the last purchase make the shoe less comfortable. Leather upper texture is different, harder. I should have returned them prior to wearing them. I thought I was safe buying same style as previous purchases. I will not purchase online again only in a store.

I have purchsed these shoes before and they always worked great, this time the shoes are very tight. I have not worn them.

Shoe fit too large. Had to return.

The shoes did not arrive new. They were sent from Williamsburg outlets where the right shoe had been worn as a display. Arrived in a box with nothing else like previous shipments. Really disappointed. Probably will not buy anymore of your products.

I returned the shoes. They were dirty. I was expecting to get a another pair and nothing has shown up.

Extremely comfortable and stylish, however they squeek extremely bad on any kind of tile.

do not like the sole and the squeaking on certain surfaces

For me a slip-on shoe should be durable, look good and fit like a glove. I would give the look of the McGuffey a better grade if you changed the sole. The one-piece leather over the box is nice. However, a little heavier thicker leather would add to the durability and versatility. The sloppy fit was the killer for me. The median width was way too loose, and the length was probably a half to full size too long making my heel come out of the shoe.

These shoes make an embarrassing squeak on most hard surfaces.

Not even close to being the correct size. My guess is the shoes were 3 sizes too large.

Love the shoe but the insole came loose.

The leather finish was defective. Colors became exaggerated.

Unfortunately the fit was not as expected. The insole was uncomfortable in the toe area, and the top portion of the shoe was too large. The materials were very rubbery and cheap. Overall the shoe looked and felt very poorly made.

Sizing is smaller and tighter than usual for JM shoes. Didn't fit. Toe box too small.

Poor construction. Sole white stitching separated from top of shoe.

Returned for credit

I have other J&M pairs of shoes but this time it was bad quality,colors was faded and dull,also material was stiff,overall quality went down significantly then my previous shoes. I returned it and waiting for refund.

Have purchased this show many times over the year, however the quality of te leather has gone downhill recently

This is my third pair of this same shoe. I wore the first two pair out. They were the most comfortable shoes i had ever owned. This pair is horrible. They do not fit the same. Materials seem different. No matter how much they are worn they do not break in.

I had previously purchased a pair of these same shoes and loved them so much that when production started back I ordered 2 more pair. The new pair I am wearing, the inner sole has come loose, the stretch material between the tongue and shoe has come loose and the webbing is coming loose from several areas of the sole after just 3 months. The new shoes are not made near as good as my originals or quality control has dropped at your plant.

Sharp looking shoe, but essentially a tool to give you plantar fasciitis. My feet kill me the day after wearing these.