Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey Slip-On

Looks beautiful, feels comfortable. Probably should be an $85-$100 shoe. Big problem with sizing- maybe this is just a recent production run, but I ordered an 8.5 and it's probably 1.5inches too long. Sent back and ordered an 8... still way too long. 7.5 is on the way, but backordered. And I think it will still be way too big.

When I received the shoes I saw that they were already tried on from a local store. The reason I know that is because inside underneath the lip of the shoe was a pinch pad that a salesperson would use to sell a pair of shoes that might just be to big. That's a no no on a quality shoe.

I wear a size 9 in all my shoes. I tried these on and they are 1-1.5 sizes too big.

Blisters. Own same shoe purchase 2 years ago and not the same,

I received a sale ad yesterday- on sale before I even unboxed shoes.

Love the look but, they are like a slipper and have no structured body to them. Maybe it is J&M's intention, but not what I was looking for.

uncomfortable shoe

I decided to purchase Johnston&Murphy shoes because I used to own a pair, but I do recommend that they get purchased at the store because they can be inspected and truly fitted. Only pictures versus what I got is not a fair comparison, colors look different and for the price honestly not worth how they feel.

not for me.

Good looking shoe but I have not worn it much because there is not enough support in the shoe. When I wear the shoe my back bothers me!

I have owned several pair of your shoes. These are by far the cheapest looking shoes I have ever received. The uppers look more like vinyl than leather. I loved your products, but I think it is time to try something else.

color does not match the catalog or the belt

Not quite what I expected. The fit was wider than anticipated and the structure of the shoe was not very supportive. It would not have been a good walking shoe.

The woven design makes these shoes stylish. The comfort level is similar to other name brands. But at 135 dollars a pair, they are not good value in my opinion.

Love the look and style. However these are not comfortable to wear more than an hour. There is little cushion compared to other JM shoes. If you like the look and will not be on your feet all day then go for it.

The shoes are nice, but too big to wear in comfort. Might try with pads stuck in heels.

Feel too big and bulky

Returned shoes

Shoes got soaked Color is now faded Disappointing as I like these

The stitching is coming out and I only wore them one weekend. Was normal wear. I have written a review before with no response. I was happy to purchase these but disappointed.

Ive been waiting for the right moment ot wear my new J&Ms. I thought a wine tour would be the perfect time in Mexico. I wore them for the 1st time for 3 days in a row with average walking on normal terrain. The topstitching has started to come out already and I dont mean a fly away. I noticed that in a couple other areas the same may be starting. I want to wear these for everyday use but I am scared for the money they wont hold up. Not sure what to do.

Johnston & Murphy typically makes quality shoes but these are unfortunately not one of them. Although they are very comfortable and fit perfectly, both shoes squeak in the heel...every step I take. Being that they are only a few months old, I am extremely disappointed as the squeaking is not only annoying to me but it's loud enough for others to hear. The squeaking began on the left shoe pretty much right after I purchased them but it was pretty unnoticeable. Not only has it progressed, but the right shoe is now just as bad. Think twice before purchasing these shoes!

After I received these shoes I noticed a discoloration, It's like both shoes were dipped in oil up up to the toe caps. At first I thought that was the design, so I checked the catalog, but unfortunately for me I got a bad pair. Too bad because I really like this company.

The shoes were much darker than shown on multiple pictures. Also the back patch was sewn crooked and was very noticeable. I returned the shoes. They were very comfortable but not what I ordered or expected