Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Mcguffey Slip-On

Bought for style & comfort but the toe material is very sensitive to contact

Wear it to work

I mostly love these shoes but I am disappointed in the color-quality of the gray ones I ordered. They look sort of a dirty (almost subtle brown tint) gray and the color gets worse with wear. They just didn't stay new looking very long. I think it has something to do with the dye used. Other than that, I love the versatility and comfort of this show.

I used it gently but wore off really quickly

Like the product immensely, color is tough to maintain.

I wear it to travel. Very comfortable but the right shoe is already coming apart

attractive shoe, tight fight

mesh rips pretty easily. Side part of sole gets dirty quickly

Thought I was buying black. Color wasn't clearly indicated. Nice shoe but not what I was expecting. Site should have been more transparent.

This is an excellent casual shoe, for sure. It's comfortable, lightweight, stylish, with an interior lining that is pleasing to the eye, a rubber soul in that grips the ground well, and overall feels just wonderful. The catch is that, unfortunately, the fabric material used for the upper lining stains very easily. In fact, I have a stain from rainwater...water! Very strange indeed. For the money, I'd consider buying a pair again...to wear around the house.

The preparations are too small to allow airflow and it is not the cool summer shoe that I was hoping for... I wish I could return it.

I like the shoe but was disappointed that after first wearing the upper began to pull away from the sole in one place opening a small hole.

The shoe is very nice and comfortable . Great casual shoe. Normally wear an 11.5 or 12 but the 11 fit me perfect

The leather weaving sure didn't take long to start ripping apart.

Quite good overall

They are ok

I bought 3 pairs. Blue, Brown and Navy. The brown pair inside sole squeaks terrible. Not sure why but it's very annoying. Beware and walk around the store in them to make sure they don't squeak

Nice soles inside, but the white sole outside gets dirty to quick and makes the shoes look old.

Bought online

Pricey ,heavy slip on, could be lighter

Shoe fit small

I liked the look and comfort initially but in just 2-4 time wearing start looking old on toes. May be there is a way to clean it

I really wanted to like this shoe. In fact I was ready to buy all the colors. After the first time wearing it with no show socks, however, they cut the back of my heal. Now I wear them with ankle length socks, and they seem OK. They are also not well ventilated, so wear the lightest weight socks you have or your feet will heat up. I've decided to go with canvas slip ons for the other colors I want.

It's a comfortable shoe that looks good with many different combinations- shorts, jeans, etc. But the grey color makes it appear somewhat dirty after a few wears. Granted, I'm not going jogging in mud or anything. Nevertheless, the grey color (my color shoes were grey) makes it hard to tell if they appear dirty or not.

It is a comfortable slip on shoe. It lacks support and cushioning.