Customer Reviews Merrell Siren Edge 3 Waterproof

The fit was true to size. My feet are narrow, so it didn't bother me. I'm used to the low profile Merrell vibram so it is taking me a while to get use to them. Overall, it is not a bad sneaker.

Waterproofing is excellent. Sturdy and great on all terrains for hikes. Arch support is weak and could use more cushioning for longer hikes

I usually need to go a half size up in Merrell shoes for proper fit, but this time my usual 7.5 length fit well but only in the wide width ( I usually don't need a wide width, although my feet certainly like room to spread out). I like that this is a lighter weight hiking shoe than other Merrell low hiker options, but sturdier than some trail runners I tried for moderate day hikes. I wear ankle high Keene or Salomon hiking boots for longer day hikes, rough terrain or backpacking, but expect these will be a fine option for less aggressive day hikes.

I thought I would wear the same size as usual but these ran small. Also, even though I wanted waterproof, they have a kind of crispy sound when I tried them on. Not 100% sure about these.

My fourth pair of these. I am a frequent hiker/walker and these shoes are perfect right out of the box. I size up 1/2 size for plenty of room for thick socks. They are a bit stiffer than a regular tennis shoe and I prefer the rigid support for walking over rocks and gravel. The grip tread is great.

True to size and width. This is a firm shoe with support which is good for me since I'm on my feet all day. I'm not crazy about the toe guard design. Wish it was a solid color. Merrell's are reliable!

I ordered 9 1/2 M. Shoe seemed a little narrow at ball of foot. They didn’t hurt or pinch my foot, just felt very snug. I walked around inside my house trying to determine if they felt too snug, & couldn’t tell. I ordered & received 9 1/2 W. Although it felt roomier across ball of foot, the heel was noticeably loose, slipping as I walked. Plus the side of the heel hit my ankle bone & I could tell that would be a problem. In the end I decided neither worked for me. Disappointing because the shoe is good looking & I really liked the stiff sole.

These felt true to size. I normally take a 10 in athletic shoes and these fit well. I have a moderately narrow foot and do put in my own insoles which probably take up a bit more space than the factory insoles. They are very firm soled and the material is more stiff than my non-waterproof Merrells as I expected. Overall they feel supportive. As with my non-waterproof Merrell Siren Edge shoes the laces do not stay tied without double knotting. Kind of annoying but not a deal breaker for me.

I loved these! They look great and would have fit my needs exactly *if* they had fit me. Sadly, they did not. Too narrow in the toe box and too loose around the heel. I almost kept because I liked them so much, but the last thing I need is another pair of shoes that aren’t quite comfortable. Was bummed to send them back.

I liked the look of these shoes and they fit well except for the toe box. There was not enough room for my bunion and so I had to return them. I love Merrell shoes and generally they fit well.

I normally wear a 9M in most shoes, a 9W in others. I ordered these in 9M and 9.5M (because the color I wanted did not come in wide). The color in the pictures is spot and and true to color. These are very good looking trail shoes. The 9M was a half size small all around - too short, too tight. The 9.5M was so close to perfect. The length was right and the toe box around the big toe was great, BUT the shoe is extremely tight at the pinky toe. It's very strange to have such room and comfort at the big toe and joints, but so tight at little toe. Sadly, am returning.

At first these shoes were very comfortable, but after wearing them around the house for a half hour it was clear they wouldn’t work for me. The top of the heel rubbed against a bone in my ankle. Not sure if I’m explaining it right, but it turned red from the rubbing. I have a pair of Merrell hiking boots that are great, but the heel on these hiking shoes come up too high.