Customer Reviews Comfortiva Cordia

Love this style. Had to return because they were too large. Wear 91/2 in sandals especially but returned for a 9 and all is good

I absolutely love these boots. So comfy and classic. They fit my orthotics without them affecting the boot's overall look, too. Only knocking them down a star because it's obvious how very thin and cheap the leather is and how fast it will start to fall apart. If these boots were less than $50 that wouldn't be an issue, but at this price point I'd expect more than a season or two of wear out of them. From experience with this type of leather, I'll be shocked if they last all the way through one fall season. Note: I use some pretty bulky 3/4 length rigid Rx orthotics. I'm usually an 8.5 or 9 in the shoes I can actually fit those beasts into...sometimes the W version of one of those sizes. Based on the all-over-the-place reviews of the size and width, I tried to order all 4 of those sizes of this boot to see what fit me best. They were out of the 8.5W, but I tried the 9, 8.5, and 9W. Despite my fairly wide orthotics and the many reviews saying that this boot runs narrow, the standard wide 9 fit both me and my orthotics perfectly. Even the regular 8.5 fit well everywhere except the toe box, which did feel a bit snug in the width on the inner/big toe side, which is an area where my orthotics don't sit...but that still could have been affected by the overall space taken up in the boot by my orthotic. I was swimming in the 9W. Maybe the 8.5W would have fit just as well as the regular 9, but tbh I'm not sure because I didn't need more width anywhere else than that one part of the toe area and the 9W was *so* much wider than the 9 everywhere.

Gorgeous boots. I need more arch support for city walking, and these are pretty flat, with only a thin layer of foam.

Excellent soft material, however the wide is still too narrow.

I found the boots to be a bit narrow towards the front of the shoe, and I do not usually wear a wide shoe. I also thought that some of the leather around the ankle was a bit thin, especially for this price point. However love the style, look and color of this boot. U fortunately they jus,t didn’t work for me.

Made of thinner material than expected from the price, and the soles seem obviously glued on. I've worn it a few times so far and it looks cute

The leather uppers are soft and the shoe had no break in period. I periodically had to tighten the laces and they seem to come untied easily but overall the shoe is comfortable and good looking!

I purchased these in brown a few years ago and loved them so much I tried to order them a year or two after but they weren’t available. I took a chance and checked again and was thrilled to see them back! Unfortunately they only had extra wide in my size (I needed wide) but they’re still very comfortable and I love the blue color! They have great support and I love the worn look. Even my old ones look the same as they did when I bought them! Highly recommend these shoes!

I really like them, I will enjoy them for years to come. The material is a little thinner than I expected, but I will see if they last. But they fit well and look good so I am very happy.

These shoes were purchased for a wedding on a mountaintop. It was the first time I wore them and they were comfortable all day long. The leather is very soft and thin which made them extra nice for a good fit. I didn’t have to worry about any blisters because the leather conformed to my foot. The ankle width of the bootie is a bit larger than usual but that will accommodate thick socks rolled down. Unfortunately they do tend to scuff up very easily. These are definitely my go to shoes for running around.

These are the perfect “granny boots “ I’ve been looking for. Just enough of a heel to be feminine but low enough to be comfy and practical. Taking some stars away bc one shoe of the first pair I received had an uncomfortable patch. I had to order a second pair which were fine, but it was a little annoying. First pair went back.

Definitely the right size length wise. After reading the reviews, I was expecting them to run narrow but the shoes were a little wide. Because of the laces, I can make them fit. The leather is very soft & I love the brown color. Exactly what I was looking for.

I wanted something I could wear with skirts and dresses and these are very cute. The leather is very thin and soft which made them comfortable from the start. I would consider these more fashion boots rather than utilitarian. I tried some lace-up boots from Born that I loved but they were stiffer and sturdier and I didn't want boots I'd have to break-in (I have plenty of those!).

Comfortable footbed, lightweight boot, like the style. I need arch support and while I might wish this boot had more, I like it enough to consider another pair in a different color.

These are very good, comfortable urban fashion boots. The leather is soft and feels great right out of the box ~ just don't expect boots that will protect your feet in the wilds, you know. Sole is thin and flexible ... maybe my one quibble since it's thin enough to, say, feel gravel through. No serious arch support, but enough room to add something. I normally wear 9.5 M but ordered 9.5 C, which feels perfect (so, the regular B width would have been too narrow). The laces are long enough that I haven't quite figured out what to do with all the excess (they come undone if I wrap to the back ... operator error, I'm sure). I'm really happy with these for my purposes. The toe detail is nice. Quality seems good.

Very pretty, cushiony sole. I ordered the 7W and fit well (normally a 6.5 or 7 and just a touch wide). Could have worn 7M but they would not fit my inserts. I wanted these so much!!! Unfortunately I had to return because the two size 7w shoes were not the same. One felt like regular width even though it was marked as wide.

Great shoes, however, I didn't order wide and they are a bit wider then my normal medium foot width. I just put on a thicker sock and they are fine. I didn't realize they were too wide when I first wore them but noticed they were roomy, then looked at the box when I returned home. All in all, they are nice and I'd order them again, only in normal width.

I'm glad I took everyone's advice and got a wide, if I hadn't I would have had to return them. These are super comfortable and fit my orthotics. The leather is very soft supple, which I like, but at the same time will definitely show wear over time. I get a ton of compliments on these boots, and a friend is going to order them in black. I highly recommend these boots!

Had to return for a 1/2 size smaller Feels like rich Italian soft leather

Love the boot, but had to return for a 1/2 size smaller. Like an Italian leather.

By far the closest to fitting me of the NINE pairs of booties I’ve now tried, these are really good-looking and—as others have said—they’re made of lovely soft leather. But one of my feet was not thrilled; I could feel its outer edge falling off the boot’s comfort sole in an uncomfortable way, and the boot itself is just a bit too narrow across the widest part of that foot. Another thing: yes, I need lots of room for my toes, but not for my heels!!! Being able to lace these babies up very tightly helped, but not enough. DARN, ‘cause they’re really nice!

These boots are a lot nicer than I thought they were. I don't think they'll hold up in the rain and snow, but they are nice for every day wear.

Awesome shoe. Size 7.5 C was a perfect size for me (my toes are a little wide, and my ankles are skinny). Very comfortable. BUT... sad to return because the color was lighter and more yellow than the photos, and it just didn't fit my wardrobe palette. If they had this same size in the Wine/Burgundy color, I'd exchange it in a heartbeat. I will try more Comfortiva shoes in the future.

Pretty boot and comfortable but decided against them because they do not seem sturdy enough for what i need to get me through winter even here in mild winter California. The leather is very soft and the heels are ultimately too high for my every day use. Finally, the style is so much like so many boots i have worn many years past that i just kind of didn’t want to look at them anymore.

Love the look and color of these boots. Leather is very soft and width is slightly narrow.