Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Button Lug Tall

Well let me say this they are beautiful and smell amazing.. Now let me get to the nitty gritty, they are tight, but I was bound and determined to get those suckers on one way or another. With the help of my kids holding them so I could stuff my foot in. As I'm about to pass out from all that strenuous exercise my foot is in... I did it.. They are nice oh crap now I gotta take them back off.. By now the kids and husband are falling on the floor laughing...one kid holds the boot the other is pulling my leg out.. Needless to say if your calf is more than 15 inches get the wide... I am having mine stretched as we speak...

I ordered the Melissa Button Two, Melissa Button Two Extended, and the Melissa Button Lug Tall. The Melissa Button Lug tall WON! I ordered my normal size 9 and they fit great. I have normal size calves and all three boots fit fine. Two little loops on each side of the boot help you pull them on for the first time. The lug heel looks super cute with jeans or a casual dress. The Melissa Button Two does have a very form fitting calf, but the extended almost seemed to roomy. My calves measure 14 1/2 inches at their biggest point (I heavy weight train). No calf issue with any of the boots.

I purchased both the cognac and the slate colors and like both equally. The gray was a surprise, it goes with almost everything and is a more casual look than black. I wear a size 11 but one foot is more like an 11 1/2 and these fit both feet without pain. They did stretch out and are much easier to yank on now. The loops on the sides make it so much simpler than my other tall Frye boots. And, yes, the new leather smell is quite divine! The slate pair also seems to have a water resistant coating of some sort which is a nice addition that I wasn't expecting. I live in the Northeast and these make great mild day winter boots with the lug sole so I don't always end up wearing pack boots everyday. Not good on ice, though. Love them!

After binge watching Longmire, my inner cowgirl spoke to me and I decided I needed a pair of boots--not sissy zip up the side boots--real boots--but not genuine cowboy boots. The Frye campus 14L looked like a good boot without going full cowgirl but when I saw the Melissa boot I couldn't decide. So I ordered both. I guess I'm not a real cowgirl--the campus boots just didn't feel right and they didn't look real cute (too wide around the ankle) but I loved the Melissa tall boot. I'm either an 8.5 or 9. My foot is on the wide side but too narrow for a wide. I read up on how boots are suppose to fit--a little snug in the front and a little slippage at the heel. When you put your foot in it is suppose to be a little difficult then go "plop" as it finally slides in. Those 8.5s were too tight. I didn't want to walk around and "break them in" in case I needed to send them back. I wore them for about ten minutes--sitting then standing then sitting then standing. When my feet kind of felt like they were going numb I pulled them off and tried on the 9s. Much much better. They're kind of snug on the calves but not super snug (I'm not skinny and I'm not fat). They for fine over leggings. Tried them on over fitted leg jeans (not skinny jeans) and they worked. Will they slouch after awhile? Maybe. But they aren't tight zip up boots. They are boots. And they are fabulous. I'm so glad that they fit because the leather is incredible. I got the cognac and they are so beautiful I would have been tempted to keep them even if they didn't fit and just set them in the shelf to look at. Like good leather boots they turn to your foot and they get more comfortable the more you wear them. I have two other Frye boots--one zip up and one lace--and they're 8.5. The 8.5 in these were definitely too tight. If you want real boots that look incredible then go with these. Great with boot cut jeans, great with tight jeans or leggings, and great with a dress or skirt.

Absolutely love these boots! They run big-I had to order 1.5 size smaller. They are classic in style so worth the investment & a beautiful color!

Beautiful! I have to wait for Christmas to open. They are currently under our Christmas tree. I was able to check them out and try on. Perfect Frye boots! I love them. I’m not going to lie they were super hard to get on (high end step). I had to work hard for it. Once on the fit was perfect. I ordered in my normal size. I know with time they will get easier to slide into but in all honesty even if they don’t I still think they are worth the work!

Love the boots! They look fantastic in person. They are a little tight when you first put them on but then they loosen up a bit.

Love the style of these comfortable boots, I know I will have them a lifetime.

These boots are beautiful and fit me comfortably right out of the box. I have received a number of compliments on them already, and wore them to work right away with no discomfort at all! The leather is soft and gorgeous, the shaft is not so wide it makes my calves look like stork legs (I am 5’9”, about 135 lbs), and the soles have good traction. Perfection.

I ended up ordering 3 pairs of these boots - an 8.5 thinking the comments regarding sizing would make me want that. I ended up ordering a size 8, and they fit perfectly. These are a narrow ankle boot, so I can wear them with leggings or jeans but more than one layer or thick socks, does not work. The biggest thing with these boots is the color - the 8.5 were a gray, the first 8 was more of a brown, and so I ordered again as I knew the 8.5 was NOT brown tinted. The 3rd pair, size 8 arrived and the color is the gray/smoke, not brown. Amazing! And the first 8 was a little taller and more room in the ankle. I own 4 pairs of Fryes and they definitely aren't the nice leather that I've had in the past. Both pairs are made in Mexico, just so different in the same size! I'll continue with the size 8 and see how they wear around the house before making a final decision.

the boots are beautiful and i really like them, however, i have a very high arch and since there is no zipper, i am unable to pull the boots on. I ordered these because i have thin calves & although they look like they would still be a little roomy for me, i could tuck in my pants & wear thick socks if i could get my feet in them! if you do not have high arches, these are really terrific looking quality boots! i had another pair of Frye boots for many years which i will continue to wear in my search for new boots! :-)

I love love love these but wish they came in wide calf. They run very long. I ordered an 8.5 and the calf fit but I had about 2 inches from my toes. I reordered then in an 8 and they were still too long, but tightener in the calf. I tried the regular Melissa in wide calf 8. The wide calf was perfect but too long. So, now I’m going to try a 7.5 wide calf. I am typically an 8-8.5 for reference. I prefer the lug style but will settle for the regular style if that is all I can get in wide. But, I might still try to have the lug stretched.

These boots are great. Comfortable, warm. Beautiful leather. More brown than gray for sure. I have been wearing them for 2 days straight. I didn’t have any trouble getting them on but have a fairly narrow foot and ankle. Best boots I’ve ever bought!

Didn't have a bit of trouble getting these on and off, and they are lovely. Nice thick quality leather. Smoke color is a bit more black than brown but I think it would work for either need. The boots say made in Mexico, so not sure about an earlier review stating the black box = made in China. They appear to be great quality to me.

Perfect! Love them!

These fit like a dream! i have a narrow, flat foot and I love these. I own too many Frye boots to count, these are a new fave!

These are beautiful. They were true to size and I had no issue getting them on or off, the largest part of my calf measures about 14.5 inches. I was hoping the cognac color would be much lighter in person than it is. It is a gorgeous rich color, but not what I was looking for.

These are such beautiful boots - I have thin calves and it's hard to find tall boots that don't make me look like a little kid playing dress-up. This had very little gap between my leg and the boot. The leather is beautiful and the boots are comfy. I found them really easy to pull on and off, and fit is true to size (unlike some other Frye boots). I am returning only because they are a hair too tall for me (which is my problem with most knee-length boots). Gonna go for the classic Harness 12R's instead. But I recommend these if you are taller than 5'3" and have thin calves!

These are attractive well made boots but if you have a high instep you’re going to need to size up, even then they were a wee bit snug on the instep at first but at least I could get the, on.

Love these boots! The color is great.

These look AMAZING, but I wasn't sure about comfort at first. I didn't love how they felt, but I didn't want to give up. I wore them in the house for a few days, and the leather really started to feel better. After trying one other boot, I just couldn't send these back. I've worn them a lot since then, and I'm SO glad I kept this pair. I am a photographer and do a lot of walking, and these have been perfect. Great purchase! I know they will last a long time.