Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

So pretty and trendy and in WIDE which is so rare to find all three qualities in the same shoe!

These are great looking shoes but felt a 1/2 size too big, had to return.

They look great. Did get blisters when wearing them the first time. Not the most comfortable flat.

This shoe looks sufficiently dressy for the occasions when you need to dress up but don't want to wear heels. I tried several brands in this style and for me these were the most comfortable and well-made. Wore them to a wedding and was happy to take them off at the end of the night, yet more comfortable than anything else I could have worn.

The shoe was cute and semi comfortable, but the pointed toe made my size 11 feet look huge so I returned them.

Beautiful flats! Sadly, they destroyed the backs of my feet. It definitely takes some time to break them in. Otherwise, they fit true to size and look great on the foot.

Loved these shoes! They just didn't fit me perfect. Felt there was too much toe cleavage.

Tried Wide width in both 7 and 7.5 because of the pointed toe. Athough I always wear a 7.5 both of the sizes were huge I needed to return them. Trying a 7M and hoping third time is a charm since I love the style of this flat.

I wanted to love these shoes but I felt like the toe portion only covered the tips of my toes while being comfortable across the ball of my foot.

Ran large, but with an added innersole, i made it work.

Really cute and they fancy up any outfit. They are stiff and took awhile to break in. I recommend wearing them for short periods at a time to reduce the blisters. Now that they are broken in, they are pretty comfortable. They don't seem like they'll stretch too much, which is good because then they won't slip off my feet when I walk.

The leopard ones are super cute but I have narrow feet so the toe part was way too wide. Bummed!

runs at least a half size big

I wanted to love these shoes. They're a beautiful color and sytle, but they never stopped rubbing on my heels. Also, the leather was pretty stiff, so they were starting to form a crease across the front of my foot from walking.

I normally wear an 8.5 or 9, and W when I can find it. Ordered the 8.5W and it was too long, but width was great. Exchanging for 8W with fingers crossed it's not too short. I love this style.

I really wanted these shoes to work but I absolutely could not get the correct size. They are long, and somewhat narrow. But then if you order the wide, this translates to a different size.... After 2 returns, I gave up. Giving them a 4 since they seem like they would be okay if you could just get the correct size.

These are super cute shoes. I normally wear a 10 or 10.5 depending on the shoe. I ordered these in a 10W based on reviews of them running large and they were still too big. I ended up returning them and I would have ordered the next size down if they were available.

I liked the look of these shoes, but they ran very large. I am pretty much always an 8, and these gapped so much at the heel they didn't even stay on. However, they fit well enough in the toes that I suspected if I went down a size they would pinch.

so cute, but big. my feet slipped out trying to walk in them.

I ordered these in 11 M Black Multi Venezia Metallic Jacquard. The shoes are beautiful, unfortunately the sides were too tight at the pinkie toe. Depending on the shoe, I am normally a 10.5-11. Perhaps if this were an 11 W or an 11.5, these might fit better. Unfortunately I will have to return these.

I love d'orsay shoes! Reading other reviews, I ordered a 1/2 size up and they were quite big. Reordering my size and hope they work. Like others have said, they are cut pretty low over the toes but I'm ok with that. I think I sill order a wide just for comfort.

Oh how I wanted to love these. They are super cute, and comfortable too despite being pancake flat. However there isn't enough of the top of the shoe to cover my "toe cleavage" and I just can't do it. It makes my foot look very unattractive and squished, despite an otherwise great fit.