Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

Very cute but was a full size too large I’d say. I’ve wearing Sam Edelman for 10 plus years and never needed another size but my true size 7. If a 6 comes in stock again I will definitely reorder!

These are adorable shoes that look like the pictures, but they fit huge. I ordered my usual size, 9.5W, and the heel wouldn't stay on my foot. I would need a 9W and possibly even an 8.5W, which I never wear, to make this work.

I ordered these in Oatmeal Kids Suede and Naturalizer Samantha in Taupe. Unlike the Naturalizer, these showed toe cleavage and had less securing the shoe to my foot so they flopped a bit as I walked. Also, the suede came with a small scuff in the leather already and I was concerned about scuffing / staining as opposed to the regular leather. The Naturalizer had a little bit more padding / support, so I decided to stick with the Naturalizer shoe instead.

I love the look of the shoes, but I truly need a *wide* width and they just hit the wrong place on my bunions. They are pretty stiff, too. But I would have put upwith that if the width worked.

Maybe it's my feet, but the point of the toe literally didn't cover the joints of my toes. Looked very odd. I usually love Sam Edelman, and these look adorable. Just not on me.

I wanted to love these but I had to return them because there’s no traction on the bottom. I almost slipped and fell on my title floor when trying them on. They’re cute and a smidge big but I would have kept them if I didn’t almost fall.

Usually wear 8.5 in Sam Edelman- these are very tight and narrow in the toe area. Returning and sizing up and hope they fit

These are really cute shoes, but the toe box was not wide enough for my foot. They squeeze my toes to where it's painful.

Great shoe. Runs extremely large.

Am a size 9 and the 8.5 was flopping off my feet. Very nice shoe, otherwise.

I'm typically a 9 and these size 8 shoes fit.

Very cute shoe. Returned because sizing is unpredictable. Previously ordered same pair a half size up and it was too large. Ordered this pair and it was too small.

Gorgeous but runs large

I have tried this style on in 3 different colors and materials and all of them fit completely different. I am a 8.5 or 9. I tried these on in the same material but different color in a 9 and they were too big, so I thought 8.5 would be great - these are way too small, but I tried a 8:5 in a different color and 8.5 was way too big - the style is cute but clearly isn’t meant for my foot :(

The fabric is stiff with no give. Looks beautiful though! Returning them

So right in the pictures, but so wrong on foot. First, major issues with the fit. Though they felt true to size, these shoes slipped off my heels with each step, perhaps, because they don't flex; even the leather upper feels uncomfortably stiff and unrelenting. Further aggravating matters, the outer sole lacks traction and felt incredibly slick on wood flooring. The thought of walking over a sidewalk grate or polished office floor sends a shiver down my spine. No arch support, but Sam Edelman shoes rarely offer any, so I knew that at purchase. I wanted to love the style, but it didn't win either. The pointed toe made my (admittedly) long feet look longer. Other pointed toe shoes have worked for me, but not these. Needless to say, I'm returning.

I was very disappointed in these shoes. They do not look like high quality shoes. In all honesty, it was hard for me to rate them for comfort since they were way too big. I ordered them in the size a usually wear. If you order, consider ordering smaller than you usually do. If you usually need a wide shoe, you will not in this shoe. Sending them back.

Very nice shoe out of the box and it fit when I put it on. But I didn't like how much feet "spread" in the middle of the shoes. So they went back.

I typically wear an 8 to 8.5, and I have a wider foot, although I usually order a medium. I ordered the 8.5 W and it was way too long. Even out of the box it looked like a 9.5. Cute shoe, just too big.

This shoe was too big. It slipped a ridiculous amount when I put them on.

These are adorable. Perfect for work or with jeans. I wore them one day. By noon i felt a slight rubbing on my heels. By 5 pm they had rubbed holes in my heels like nothing I have ever seen. I am 2 weeks out and can only wear open back shoes because my heels are in such horrible condition. I will obviously be throwing these in the donation bin.

Returned as they don't fit.