Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

It was cute, but too much toe crotch

I like these, but my foot constantly slips out of them if my feet are a little bit cold. They just don't stay on very well. They look lovely and maybe I'll get used to them, but for now it's hard to keep them on.

I love the look of these and have them in the light blue snake skin. I ordered black in the same size but they were too small. Sad to send them back because the price is amazing.

I like the style of these shoes, but found them hard to keep on my feet. The color was lighter then I wanted so I had to return them.

The shoe fits nicely and looks very cute. To be honest, it's not the most comfortable shoe, as often man-made materials don't often have flexibility. I still like them but I can't spend a whole day walking around town in these. Love the print though.

I usually love Sam Edelman shoes and I so wanted to love these. The oatmeal suede color was beautiful but the top toe area was just cut too low for my foot and looked awkward. Might be a better fit for someone with long narrow feet. Was sorry these had to go back.

These are beautiful shoes but my pain-in-the-foot feet just had problems with them. I am a 9.5 wide. The toe area rubbed and they were 1/2 too size big. The actual width was perfect. I hope they work for you.

Very cute style. I am regularly a 7.5. A little big. I realize the toes are pointy and this is probably to compensate, but my foot is loose in the back heel and my toes are not fully covered.

So bummed. Tried an 8.5W (normally wear an 8.5 and typically find SE to be a bit narrow for me) but too large in width and length. Ordered an 8N and too short and narrow. On the wait list for an 8W... we’ll see if that does the trick.

Initially these shoes were a bit tight for me. After a few wears, they stretched....but then kept on stretching. Now they are falling off my feet as I try to walk (wearing 1-2x/week for <1 year).

I wea only flats and typically a size 9, sometimes 9.5 if shoe runs small. I have several pairs of Felicia (Sam Edelman) in 9.5 but this Rodney shoe was too big in 9.5 on my right foot (my left foot is slightly longer). The size 9 looked exactly right (no gaps anywhere) but the shoe is rigid, so there was pressure on specific spots. The shoe looked so darn cute in leopard print, I took the leap and wore them to work. First off, got compliments about how cute shoe looked. I was wearing pantyhose so I think that helped prevent blisters. They are not comfortable but they weren’t killing my feet. That said, by 8pm (I worked late), a spot on my left heel and a spot on top of right big toe was smarting. Bit quite a blister, but on its way to becoming one. Bummer. I will continue to wear them, hoping to break them in. If they had been comfortable out of the box, I would’ve bought more colors as it really does look cute and classy on my foot. Really dresses up any outfit.

Super cute flats but unfortunately they did not work for my foot. I have a high arch and the gap between my foot and the shoe is highlighted by this style. I also have a wide front to my foot and the pointed toe was to narrow with the heel being too wide.

These are very pretty shoes but the style was a little dressier than i wanted. Plus the pointed toe might have been a little too long - instead of my feel looking normal sized and elegant, I felt they were elongated a little too much, especially with the jeggings I was wearing with them. I wore the shoes around the house and they were slippery and loud on hardwood floors. That would probably resolve itself after a few wearings outside. Also, the base was very stiff -so if they were loose at all, they'd flip off instead of bend with my feet. All in all, if they had just a little be more of a casual look, I'd have kept them and hoped wearing them in a little with resolve the stiffness and slippery sole. The leopard pattern is cute and the coloring true to the image on the website.

beautiful and grace ful but I walked right out of them. I could not go down in size, I wouldn't get into the toe box. Disappointed.. Might work for otherv feet.

These shoes are very pretty and versatile and will upgrade any outfit. I normally wear a 39 EUR or 8 and ordered a 8.5 and if fits great. I don't think they are great walking shoes, more to wear to the office or somewhere you know you will not be walking a lot.

Super cute for the fall with a pair of jeans or ankle pants!

Very cute shoe and I wanted to love it, but the toe was a little too tight and my heel slipped out. It just wasn’t comfortable enough to keep.

Run big. I wear 8.5-9.0 and I bought a 9. They fit my med-width foot about 1/2 size too big. A tiny bit of toe cleavage shoes, which is fine. But they're a bit too pointy - the pointed toe gets crushed when you walk. They're also super slippery on the sole. I have another pair of Sam pointed-toe in size 9.0 and don't any of these problems. If you're in between sizes, I would order both to try on. They are pretty comfortable like all SE shoes. A pretty shoe, but I wouldn't pay $100 for them again.

I usually wear a 7W, but these were quite a bit too big in that size. Love the style though!

I am usually a 6 or 6.5 and the 6 fit perfect. The 6.5 was too big. The heel slips a little so I took a star off for that. I bought those heel stickers and they stay put now. They look fabulous!

I never know what size to buy in SE shoes. I bought a 6.5 and they were snug, but I figured they would stretch out. They did. . .too much and now they slip off of the back of my feet. I've tried the heel sticky things, but the inside of the shoes are a suede-like material that makes it difficult for the sticky heel things to stay in place. I've worn them for 2 days to work and now I"m afraid I cna't wear them anymore.

These shoes are beautiful. I don't wear heels. EVER. So I needed a shoe that felt pretty, dressy, sexy, you name it. And these flats are IT. I typically wear an 8 or an 8.5 in shoes, and I typically need a decent size toe-box. I ordered the 8.5 and I think I'm happy with the way they fit. They look the teensiest bit big in the back, BUT they do not slip off my feet when I walk whatsoever, and we all know feet swell in the summer and when walking or standing around a lot. And these are shoes I'd prefer to fit a little loose than a little tight. Surprisingly the toe-box isn't tight in the least and I have virtually no toe cleavage (not that that would bother me with these shoes). The only reason for the 4-stars is that I haven't worn them for very long yet. I got the more subtle of the two leopard prints and they really are the perfect "neutral" -- just interesting enough. I couldn't be more pleased. Don't get too hung up on the mixed reviews about fit, at least try them.