Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

I think these shoes are absolutely perfect!

I usually wear a 8.5/9 W and ordered a 8.5W. My foot was slipping out and maybe 8W would work. Instead I got another Sam Edelman flat with the same leopard calf hair, which I really love and hope it wears well.

These shoes are beautiful. They are sparkly enough for a dressy/casual day look or a night time dressy look with a skirt or dress.

My Mom bought these for me for Christmas so I have only tried them on so far. They seem like they will be pretty comfortable. I like that they don’t make my feet look wide.

I have a really flat feet so, finding a flat shoe that works is hard. I love these flats and plan to order more colors in them!

I have tried these on around the house and since it's December I probably won't be wearing them for a while but I just have to say they are very pretty and stylish. There is a bit of toe cleavage as others have said but not much. I read the suggestions to order one size down but they didn't have that size for me so I ordered my normal and it seems to fit great. I have had such a hard time finding navy blue flats that I'm thrilled to have found these. They're keepers.

Pretty shoes, good fit

Love these shoes! Ordered leopard, they look great and go with a variety of styles, colors, prints, etc. They are well made, and feel slightly bigger than the usual 7, but not quite a full half-size bigger, which I assume is due to the d'orsay style. I did get a blister on my heel and one on each of my second toes, but I find this to be the usual experience with such shoes and I don't consider it a drawback, as once they are broken in, they feel wonderful. I did wear them around the house with socks initially, which helps breaking in and minimizes blisters (for me). So glad I got these!

Bought these in calf hair for my daughter who needs slick bottoms. She fell in love with them so bought them in blue as an Xmas gift. They fit well but a little, but not much, toe cleavage shows. If you don't want any to show at all these are not shoes for you. She finds them to be very comfortable.

Just rec'd these today and I love them but they have to go back for a smaller size. They definitely run large. Width is fine but too long. I can get my finger in the heel, so I must size down to keep them on. I hope that works because they re so pretty and stylish. I hate I have to wait again!!!

Sooooo adorable, but they run a little big.

Love these classic flats!

Perfect flats!

Love be them! Perfect cool neutral to pick up most outfits. I wouldn’t wear them in bad weather or a day I was walking tons. But the work for most days for me.

Bought these for my daughter. Wonderful fit and she just loved them. There was a little "toe show" due to the low cut but not enough that she cared. She has MS and must have flat leather soles. She fell in love with them at first sight. A 7 1/2M is her size and these fit well. Overall, a little pricey but worth the look & fit.

Such a pretty shoe. Looks cuter in person and I love love the style. I am normally a size 8 and first ordered a 7 1/2 since others said it ran big; however, that was not the case for me. I returned the 7 1/2 and re-ordered in an 8. The 8 fits, but is a little tight in the toe area. I ended up wearing them to hopefully break them in more as I think the wider width would have been too large. Overall cute shoe I am hoping I can break in a little to make them more comfortable.

The shoe was exactly what I was looking for and fit true to size. I have a decently narrow foot and the medium width was great. Lots of toe clevage, but that’s fine with me... gotta have clevage somewhere!

These shoes fit perfectly, the leopard print is beautiful and they are very comfortable.

Great shoe! Wearing under my gown for my daughters garden wedding. Then on to my heels for reception. The shape of the toe makes it appear as if it is a heel, extremely comfortable. Excited to wear them with jeans! They are def a forever shoe!

I love love love this shoe. Stylish and comfortable. I have arthritis in my feet and spend most of the day in orthopedic shoes but when I want to look nice I wear Sam Edelman. They are super comfortable for what they are. I have a pair in taupe and black as well.

Gorgeous shoe. The wide sizes run at least a half size too large. Could not fix with inserts.

As a follow-up to sizing.... I have a wide foot and usually wear a 7.5M depending on the toe box. Thinking the very pointed toe would be an issue I ordered this show in 7W and 7.5W. Surprisingly both were too wide. Zappos, true to form, got the 7.5M to me in one day and they fit well! Great looking flat! Thanks, Zappos!

Great navy blue color. I ordered Wide because of such a pointed toe and will need to return the 7.5W to a 7W. Style will be perfect from jeans to dress. Zappos, as always, your customer service and speedy shipping is greatly appreciated!

This would be an update on a review I made yesterday. I exchanged my shoes for a half size smaller, and I believe they are going to work! I read all of the reviews about getting the wide shoes if you have a medium foot, so that’s what I did. I regularly wear 8 1/2-9, so first time I ordered, I went with an 8 1/2W– they were TOO BIG!!! Falling off my feet big, I think it was because I ordered the wide. I exchanged them for an 8 W and they are great! I can’t wait to wear them!!