Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

This shoe met my expectations for overall comfort and fit. True to size, these flats are a fun addition to any wardrobe. I love them so much, I have two pairs! Such a versatile shoe! I can easily wear them for day or evening.

Wonderful shoe. Very stylish with good quality leather. The only reason that I gave the fit 4 stars was due to the fact that in the summer time, my feet swell which made the shoe slightly tighter.

I liked it and it was well made and a rich navy blue. But I returned it because I could see my toes, which I'm not a fan of. Toe cleavage! Also the sides were very low even for a D'Orsay pump and for a work shoe I felt like my foot was very exposed.

I love this shoe, I wear a size 4 and it's so hard to find a shoe like this, I wish all colors came in size 4.

I love this style shoe and have it in 5 colors. It accommodates my bunion and I can add my own stick on silicon arch support. All day comfort and style perfection!

Nice quality shoe, but runs large.

These are very elegant flats - I think they definitely look more expensive and high-end than they are. Really beautiful - they've already become my go-to black flats and I ordered a second pair in neutral suede.

I am so glad I read more than 5 reviews on these shoes - I just got these flats today and I am IN LOVE with them!! The color is so gorgeous (got the Cranberry) but the reviews are SO TRUE - order a size smaller in WIDE (if you dont have extremely narrow feet) I am true to size 8M and I ordered a 7W; they fit perfectly. Something to keep in mind, if you dont have long toes expect to have more than just toe cleavage. These happen to for work me since.. well, I have longer toes! The only thing negative I can say is the fact that these aren’t true to size; I would’ve been an unhappy customer had I not fully read the reviews.

I ordered these in the exact same size as my other Sam Edelman ballet flats (6 W), and they were so long, I couldn't keep them. They had a full inch in the back, my foot didn't even touch the end. So sad! I'll try the 5.5 and hope they fit. The are really nicely made, cute cut, and the animal print is so classic!

Love love love...very comfortable and cute. Flats don't always like me I ordered a half size down and a wide and they are perfect. I hope they get black in wide soon I will totally get those too. I usually wear an 8 I went with a 7.5 and I go back and forth between regular and wides depends on the shoe.

Glad I didn’t go off of the reviews, these fit perfect ! They are comfortable and the perfect nude color. These are to date, my favorite shoes! ????

Love them! Perfect nice color!

Comfy. Great for work, if you are looking for comfort, and a rest from heels.

Adorable but just like all flats that are cute they have no arch support but for an evening out they work

These are beautiful shoes of excellent quality. Although I can usually wear a pointed toe shoe, the toe section was a little long for my foot and I don't think a smaller size would work. I regret having to return them. Definitely worth a try.

Very cute, just a little long for me.

Fit was true to size but a little tight across if you have any bunion at all. Feels like it will get better with additional wear. Super cute.

I really love the look, however, they feel stiff and they need to be broken into. Beware if you have a wide foot, these shoes are very narrow on the toe area. I have narrow feet and I got a small blister on my pinky toe but the shoe stretched out a bit and now I can wear them without a problem so I'm keeping them. Overall, cute shoe but stay away if you care a lot about comfort.

Too large - I am normally a 6-6.5 and this was flopping off my feet. I think a 5.5 would have fit perfectly but it doesn't seem to come in that size, else I would have exchanged not returned.

I’ve had two operations on my left foot. As a result, I’m always looking for cute flats. These are really cute, but are a bit long. I’m hoping the addition of a foot pad will add arch support and help with the length.