Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Rodney

I read all the reviews and ordered a half size smaller but I will reorder my true size. Hopng they fit..love the shoe, the color of the animal print is what I wanted.

I own several pairs of Rodneys and the fit is consistent with each pair. Comfortable cute shoe for a flat that once you break them in you can wear them all day. Heel is a bit stiff at first and def wear around the house before an all day wear out. Love the fun colors and patterns. Got these to wear with jeans or black pants...real real cute!

I absolutely love the style and animal print patter of this shoe, A little toe cleavage, but that's sexty to me, I'm obsessed with the d'orsay pointed toe cut for flats. This show goes well with slacks, jeans and my favorite go to pencil skirts.

Love these flats. They go with virtually anything you want to dress up! Being 5' 11'' I tend not to wear heels so these are a great dressy shoe for me!

These are my favorite style of flats! I now have 2 pairs! I love how they fit and how sleek they look with just about any outfit. Would love more colors!!!

I can’t wear heels anymore and needed flats for outfits that I would normally wear heels. These are a great flat to fill that void. I wear the leopard print with jeans, dresses, dress pants, skirts. Looks good with everything. I also have the patent leather which is just as versatile. I wouldn’t walk 5k in them but they are comfortable enough for the office.

LOVE the sassy, sharp look of these in black patent!! I’ve gotten so many compliments. I also ordered the French Sole Sloop and Nine West Speak Up and this shoe was the sharpest! With all patents there was a slight squeak with my big toe rubbing the inside so smeared a little Vaseline inside the toe box and voila.......no more squeak!! Returning the other two shoes and keeping these!!

I usually wear a size 10. After reading other reviews I went with a 1/2 size down and it’s perfect! Love it!

Great fit, cute style. Oodles of compliments. Animal prints are a fabulous neutral. Delighted with this purchase.

I purchased these shoes to wear to an outdoor wedding. These are amazing! I ordered a half size up from what I would normally get (normally an 8W, purchased an 8.5W) and they fit perfectly out of the box. They are so adorable and look so stylish with the pointed toe and the nearly D'Orsay sides. I feel like a princess in these shoes and I cannot wait to wear them to the wedding in September.

I ordered these in both suede and leather and chose the suede as it was a little dressier for the wedding I was going to. This is a great looking shoe that is stylish and fairly comfortable for a flat. I usually wear a 10.5 medium and ordered that size, it fit perfectly. Its a great quality shoe for the price.

LOVE these shoes but somehow they are way too big now that I’ve been wearing them all the time. I need to order a size down because I love them so much but they are no longer comfortable to wear since stretching out.

great, cute shoes.

I absolutely love the shoes! They are so classy and well-made. The leopard print is absolutely beautiful and high end. I can’t wait to get another pair in a different color.

These are beautiful shoes out of the box and on the foot. I hoped they would work as my all-purpose neutral. I have an extremely wide forefoot and the 8.5 W fit better than other dress shoes I have tried. However I was unable to walk comfortably for any distance with this design for my particular foot anatomy. Older and retired, I seldom purchase new shoes and clothes. However Zappos was superlative in every regard with this purchase experience.

Really like this d'orsey style flat. It has a nice passed insole and an ever so slight heel (still a flat) that adds to the overall comfort. I found it true to size.

I’m typically a size 8 shoe so that’s the size I got and they fit perfectly. I’ve only worn them around the house so far but they are super cute and I would buy again.

Have to break in a bit, but comfy and cute otherwise!

I love these shoes. I have a pair in the leopard print and the oatmeal. I usually wear an 8.5 but wear a 7.5 in these. Mom loved them too and so I bought her a pair. She has a wide foot and normally wears a 6.5 or 7, I bought her a 6 and they are perfect.

I normally wear a 5.5 shoe size but bought a size 5 in the Rodney and they fit perfectly. I have several Sam Edelman D'Orsay heels and they are so comfortable and look great on, so I took a chance with the flat and am very happy with the purchase. They are all well made and really cute.

Love these shoes! The nude color is a true neutral / beige, not the ubiquitous blush pink “nude” which is everywhere (don’t get me wrong, blush is a lovely shade too, but sometimes you need a true neutral beige with no hint of pink and this is it!). These shoes are comfortable to walk in and stay securely on my feet without slipping. I adore pointed toes and these do not pinch my feet at all, another plus. For me these shoes absolutely true to size (I ordered a 7.5 M). A note on arch support... there is a padded footbed, but really not much arch support. I chose “moderate” over “none” on the Zappos pull down menu, however, because I have high arches and have been miserable in other shoe brands without arch support, but these SE Rodneys are very comfortable on my feet. Overall, these are beautiful and versatile shoes which are neutral enough to be paired with countless outfits.

Perfect flat! I needed a great flat to wear with a jumpsuit and these are perfect! Dressy but not overdone! I'll be ordering the leopard print soon!

I’ve been searching for the perfect flat- cute and wearable- and this shoe fits the bill. I ordered 9W and they fit great. For reference I am between and 8.5 and 9 in most shoes and usually size to 9, or even 9.5 in flats. These feel closer to 9.5 and also seem like they may stretch. I’ll add pads if needed, and for my use, I don’t mind the looser fit. Bottom line, these avoid my bunions, are padded on sole of foot and are easy to wear out of box. I would not wear for a lot of walking, but great for short distances like to dinner or desk-based office environments.

Gorgeous shoe, I have the black Napa Leather. Definitely runs a half size big, which I’ve never experienced with Sam Edelman shoes before. But Zappos makes exchanges easy so no worries. The wide width works great for my wide foot and the toe clevage makes them looks more chic, IMHO. LOVE THEM.