Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

Cute and seemingly comfy, but had to send them back because of the strange outside sole design on the heel.

If you are going to be walking a lot in these shoes, especially on sidewalks, I would not recommend these shoes. The soles are very thin and the heel part of the sole is very firm and small and therefore is uncomfortable if not almost painful after a lot of walking. Also, the uppers start to cave in almost, near the toes, and do not maintain their shape.

I did not like this shoe. The style is right, but it was so uncomfortable when I tried it on that I wasn't going to even consider breaking it in. Been there, done that, and it's not worth it. It wasn't even an issue of sizing, because it didn't feel too small or too big - it just dug into my heel in the back and squished my toes up front. I wouldn't recommend this shoe.

My least favorite ballet flat I've ever had. Absolutely no cushioning whatsoever. You are basically walking on the sole of the shoe. The lining is synthetic which does not breathe. The shape of the shoe is nice but I can't wear these for long or very far like other flats. Look to French Sole's Sloop model for a great basic flat.

These shoes are a very tight fit. They felt one size smaller. I had to squeeze my feet into my pair.

I bought 2 pairs of these flats n different colors - after about 2 weeks of wear both have stretched out so much they are unwearable. They looked so good at first! This was an expensive dissapointment.

The worst shoe I've ever purchased. Bought in "grout" about a month ago in size 6.5 bc I'm b/w a 6.5/7. The grass was slightly damp so within about 5 min of wearing, they had a couple drops of water on them that instantly discolored them. I tried to lightly clean them and the color ran more. Then the texture started to rub away like leather/fabric shouldn't. The fit TIGHT and are extremely uncomfortable after just an hour. No support, no stretch, and somehow they are rubbing my heel despite fitting tightly. I threw them away since I couldn't return them. The soles looked brand new and the tops were destroyed after 3 days of trying to wear them.

These shoes are super cute, but the stitching at the top of the heal rubbed my foot raw. Because of the elastic in the shoe getting them stretched did not help.

I would give this shoe a 0 star overall right now if I could. They started out a 4-5 star. I have had them only about 2 months and one shoe has already fallen apart. The leather has completely separated from the sole right by my baby toe. These are not the most expensive shoes but they should at least last longer than 2 months!

Worst flats ever! Total waste of money! They are so painful to walk in for longer than a quick stroll to the mailbox. They break in very fast, and still are extremely painful to walk in. They also "splat" out awkwardly which makes your foot look super weird. Unfortunately they looked and felt fine when I first tried them on, and after a few hours of wearing them, they look worn... I tried them a second day to see if they just needed a second chance to break in, and still awful, and now after 2 days of walking outside I cant return. I keep them under my desk now as a last resort extra pair of flats to wear in the office.

These shoes are terrible. After two months of wear the soles and uppers separated. Two months! I've had cheap Target shoes last longer than that. Definitely not worth the cost.

These shoes are terrible! I had foot surgery two years ago and all has been fine until I wore these ONE time. I have now had to go back to doctor because of how these shoes hurt my foot so badly. I would NOT recommend!

These were "floppy" on my feet. Not sure if they were too big or just that they don't really have a shape at all.

Do not get these! I got them awhile back and one day it poured out and my feet turned black and the seams came loose. I didn't know it was going to rain that day either. I am still sitting here while they dry!

Beware if you buy these in black. I got the black leather ones and wore them today and it was raining. Got all the way to work and my feet were black and when I tried to take them off my fingers turned black. The material they use is poor quality and not good!

Disappointingly, these shoes are much more "peasant" looking than I expected. Very soft which was nice, but the toe is a bit too rounded for my liking. Also, the padding in the toe of the shoe stops just short of the edge and you can feel it which was annoying to me.

I run a narrow 7½/8, so I ordered a size 8M and I could barely fit my foot inside. It was seriously like trying to squeeze my foot into a size 6! It is a super cute style, but I would recommend sizing up!

These flats are very cute yet so uncomfortable that they are unwearable. There is no arch support at all and they run small. I normally buy an 8.5 and these fit like at 8. My toe rubs at the end and side of the shoe. The inside of the shoe itself is so slippery that my foot slid around and rubbed on all sides. It made it very difficult to walk. The shoe is also very shallow in terms of depth in the toe box. The interior lining is a cheap plastic like material.

I bought these a couple years ago. I really liked them but they were never comfortable. They just wouldn't break in. I finally realized that while they are leather uppers, the lining is plastic. Never could wear them for long. Fortunately, my puppy chewed a hole in them.

I wore these shoes three times. I wish I would have bought them in a different color. I have black and orange and I love them but these brown ones well. The color rubbed off and they look like I have had them for years and years though you can clearly see the bottom of the show is not even scratched up. Watch out for the color rubbing off.

I have these flats in three colors and they are super comfortable and cute for flats. My issue with this particular pair is that after just a few times wearing them, the coating is coming off in multiple places. They now look hideous and and are completely unwearable.

Hate these! So cheap, flimsy and uncomfortable. Definitely not worth the price I paid, but I already wore them once and now they are dirty. I just saw a similar pair in Charming Charlie's for less. Boo!

I am really disappointed with this purchase. I wore the shoes maybe 6 or 7 times and the color started flaking off. They looked cute when I first got them but now they look awful.

The problem with this shoe is that it shows part of the tops of your toes. I have average size feet and toes and toe lengths and the shoe is just not designed properly. Why would anyone want to see part of the tops of your toes and not the pretty nails part? I expect a "flat" to cover my toes completely (or if it's a peek-a-boo toe shoe, it can show my toenails). But why would a shoe designer, other than through utter negligence, design a shoe that shows just the beginnings of your toes? What an ugly look! This was a big bummer for me because other than that, the shoes would have been perfect. I love the color, texture, general style. I had to return them due to this flaw in their design that rendered them ugly.

I had been looking for cute flats for so long and found these so was very excited...they are truly the most uncomfortable shoes I have ever worn. My 3-4" heels are more comfortable. There is zero arch support and the elastic on the back is so stiff, that even after 6 months, I have to use band aids so I don't get blisters.